Italy’s best 3 is a pizzeria owned from a family born and raised in Napoli ( Italy ) where pizza was born. We serve the community with some delicious food since 1992. Our delivery service is pretty fast , we cover all of Toms river , highland heights, pine lake park and beachwood. There is a big difference between the big chains and the indipendent pizzeria , you will taste the difference in our products. We proudly use only the finest ingredients and everything is made from scratch. Our motto is “THERE IS A REASON WHY THEY CALL US ITALY’S BEST”
Based on 211 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
984 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 240-9449
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:45 AM–9:45 AM |
| Wednesday | 10:45 AM–9:45 AM |
| Thursday | 10:45 AM–9:45 AM |
| Friday | 10:45 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:45 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8:45 PM |
| Monday | 10:45 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
aaron charnick
We stopped here on the way home from Seaside Heights. The foods was decent at good prices. Really liked the staff! They are on top of their game! We ordered our food and it was our within 15 mins. That’s with them starting to get busy at that point. I highly recommend the Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza! The plain was ok and the cheese steak was ok. Really not the way I like it but it was ok. I would recommend stopping while in town!
… more
Dawn Jones
Our heartfelt thanks to Jason at Italy’s Best! Sadly we lost our Patriarch. Italy’s Best was Pops favorite place, with good reason. I called and spoke to a young man, Jason. A true asset to Italy’s Best. Every single detail was perfect. The service was top-notch, the food was fabulous. We had a change in time and it was as if we’re to have arrived when we did! If you’re planning a function, I would not hesitate to recommend Italy’s Best. When you call, ask for Jason and tell him Dawn sent you!! You won’t regret it!
… more
Patrice Hernandez
This is the Fourth time we have ordered Subs from this place and they never disappoint! The way they make the subs with the freshest bread,meat and ingredients are outstanding!! You can’t even fit your mouth around it, that’s how much meat they use!! This by far is the best place to get subs forget Jersey Mike’s,subway or any other pizza place! Please do yourself a favor and eat their food it’s all Amazingly Delicious!! One Satisfied Customer for Life,Great Job Guys!!!
… more
Michael Pannucci
I’m from north Jersey, and whenever I visit Toms River, this is the only pizza that I’ll get. Great quality and they make the crust just right. Also such friendly people who work there. They are always so pleasant when I come in to pick up my order. Highly recommended.
… more
Aaron Dirodrico
I have lived in toms River almost my whole life I’ve passed this place a million times I’ve never ordered anything from here. After exhausting all the other local pizzerias just being frustrated with the quality of food and the quality of food as well as the speed of delivery and if my food is hot when I got it.
… more
Rita Othello
I’ve purchased from this location personally and even referred clients for their catering. Tonight working a double ordered a chicken parmigiana dinner, requested light sauce due to the acidity. Too much sauce and one of the breast was undercooked. So , I try the soup pasta fagioli and it was loaded with white beans, oil and undercooked pasta with no taste. I called in a nutshell they won’t refund my funds and told me the chicken couldn’t be undercooked, because it comes precooked. Poor customer service and quality. Very disappointed
… more
Kristen Zielinski
I often order dinner for my family at Italys Best. Our orders are always accurate and ready on time. I love the family meal options. I can feed my household of 5 quality food at a reasonable price. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is always clean. We look forward to many more meals being prepared by them!
… more
Michele Fury
Very good pizza..light and crispy crust, seasoned sauce, and salty, but not cheap quality salty cheese, at least not to my palate. Ingredients are fresher than most.
… more
Nikole Mendez
This is hands down THE BEST PIZZA in OCEAN COUNTY! The sauce is incredible, their regular crust is always amazing and the garlic knot crust is perfection! We have ordered sandwiches, burgers, and most of their Italian dishes and it never disappoints. We’ve ordered catering as well for family parties and everyone always says how amazing the food is! The owners and all of staff including delivery are always so friendly, and go above and beyond to make sure you are happy with your order. We are so happy we found this gem! 5 Stars! Don’t hesitate try them tonight!
… more
Brianna Zielinski
My family and I tend to order from Italys Best III weekly. Even though we are out of their delivery area it is just that good we go to pick up. Our in delivery area can’t compare to Italys best food! Between the family meal deals and the margarita pie is the best! If you haven’t tried yet I definitely recommend getting one of the family meals for your family!
… more
… View more