Relaxed spot in a shopping plaza offering brick-oven New York-style pies, plus cheesesteaks & wings. Based on 267 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4005 Wake Forest Rd, Raleigh, NC 27609
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nybrooklynoriginalslicesnc.com
Reviews
Jazmany Gonzalez
Pizza by the slice is a tough task to get right… You either got a crust that’s to thin with toppings sliding off when you take a bite or a thick crust that gives your jaw a workout.
… more
Nevaeh Skye
Ordered a 8″ Philly Cheese Sandwich and 8 Piece mozzarella sticks. First time ever ordering at this restaurant and I can’t say as I’m impressed. Not only was the sub very skimpy on the meat portion, but that was the shortest 8″ I’ve ever seen in my life. At most the sub I received was 4″ and that’s being generous. It’s sad if I’m honest because the restaurant is so close to my school but quality and quantity is most certainly NOT worth the price.
… more
Mansoor
Located near Duke raleigh hospital. Service was great. Have option of calling in or doing only order. Plenty of parking. Only downside is they are not open on sunday. One of limited places in raleigh that has the gyro pizza. But overall would visit again.
… more
notdeadkev.
Staff is always friendly, food is great reminds me of the corner pizza place in Cedarhurst when I lived in N.Y.
… more
Chloe Tellefsen
Best spaghetti in raleigh!!! even compared to much much nicer places the food is unparalleled
… more
Kevin
Love this place! They have great homemade sauce that tastes delicious on their brooklyn/Margherita style pizza. My wife and I also love the spaghetti and meatballs, so much flavor!! And the garlic knots are some of the best I’ve had in Raleigh. Staff is always friendly!!
… more
John Geary
Have tried their pastas, strombolis & pizza…ALL AWESOME !!! And great customer service, quick delivery etc.
… more
Amanda Wright
This is definitely not “NY Style Pizza”. Anyone that posts a review saying it is has either never been to New York or is a friend of the owner. Very bland. Crust is definitely not fresh or hand tossed. The sauce was awful. Whatever cheese combo they use should be revisited. I got ham on my pizza and it appears as if they just threw a bunch of canned ham that you put on a salad. Definitely won’t be going back
… more
Ray of Sunshine
Been fan of this place for over 10yrs! Best Pizza in Raleigh
… more
LaKishi Frederick
My family used to frequent this establishment a few times a week. The service was great, they always seemed warm and friendly. That all changed today. I ordered two pizza’s two days ago and one was over cooked, this happened the week before when I ordered 2 individual slices. My son picked them up and I didn’t notice until I arrived home. I called and was told to bring they back, I forgot to bring them and just purchased an extra large and discarded the slices. Today I went in to replace the pizza, I did forget to call, but didn’t think it was a big deal since the pizza was intact, we order from them often and last time I was told to bring the food back. The woman just repeated two days, even before I was finished my sentence. She did acknowledge we are frequent customers and then walked away. Her husband asked to see it and said it just looks like you forgot about it, but I will remake. He could not see that accusing a customer of lying especially one who spends so much money every month is at the very least a bad decision business wise.
… more
… View more