Italian Food Company – where everyone is like family and everything is imported from Italy with Love. Experience authentic Italian cuisine, from home-cooked pastas, seafood & meat entrees, to authentic pizzas cooked in a traditional wood-burning oven. We’ve even perfected Gluten-Free pizzas made with Caputo gluten-free flour. Our menu includes delights from various regions of Italy with appetizers, salads, pastas, entrees and our famous desserts. Every location incorporates an Italian Market with imported ceramics, artisan pastas and tomato sauces, olive oils, condiments, and specialty treats. Visit us online for more information.
Based on 413 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
82779 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 780-7127
Website:
Hours
| Saturday |
5–10 PM |
| Sunday |
5–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
Closed |
| Wednesday |
5–10 PM |
| Thursday |
5–10 PM |
| Friday |
5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Ted from Florida
There were 5 of use, each ordering different meals. I wasn’t happy with my Chicken Parm, only because of their sauce. The chicken itself was great. Everyone else enjoyed their meals, hence the 4 stars.
… more
Heather Wong
We chose to have dinner here on our wedding night and we couldn’t have made a better decision. Our server Vinny gave amazing recommendations and was very charming. Food was absolutely superb. Thank you for making our wedding day special. We will be back. You might want to go here later in your trip to save the best for last.
… more
Lisa Paparella
What a find in Islamorada. The service was attentive & friendly. Atmosphere is casual. Our food was served very quickly, piping hot in an interesting assortment of casserole dishes & bowls. Everything looked amazing & tasted delicious. Portions are generous enough for sharing. We will be back when we return to the Keys.
… more
shaggy 505
There was a two hour wait for a place on the water but I am so glad we ended up here! What a cool place! Great food, service and ambiance. The mussel broth and mussels were really good, the pizza crust was thin and crispy all ingredients seemed so fresh, the arugula salad was one the best we’ve had with the citrus Dijon dressing, fresh tomatoes and shaved Parmesan. My son loved his Alfredo and the cheesecake was very good with a few fresh strawberries. The only negative was it can get very noisy and hard to hear in there.
… more
Yvonne Girard
My husband and I stopped in on our way home. We’ve never eaten real Italian food other the pizza and spaghetti you make at home so we had a hard time understanding the menu not understanding some of the words and what they meant. My husband says oh I can’t eat here I don’t know what all this food is. He happened to look over at the next table and the child was having pasta that looked really good he says I’m gonna have that. When the server came by we ordered and I’m telling you OMG that was the best plate of pasta that we have ever eaten.
… more
Michelle Brugh
What a hidden gem! We were headed someplace else but decided to try this cool little place called The Italian Food Company in Islamorada. 100% family owned and operated. Our server’s name was Giuseppe and amazing!
… more
Chelsea Loos
We are frequents to Italian Food Company and no matter what dish we get, it is delicious. We’ve been to Italy quite a bit too and it is pretty comparable. The pizza is my go to and my husband loves the Cacio E Pepe. Definitely check it out and request T.J.! He is a phenomenal server!
… more
Heather “Feather” Sellers
Walking up to the building, italian music plays gently from outdoor speakers to welcome you. Open and bright dining area, with colorful tables & seating. Salad is prepared in a renovated shell of an italian car inside the dining area!
… more
Brandy Sandor
The service was great(thank you TJ), but the food was out of this world good. Authentic Italian food. We got to watch them bake the pizza in the wood fired oven. The special of the night was exactly what you’d would want from a true Italian restaurant.
… more
Alexandra Colon
This place is absolutely beautiful and I’m glad we found this place during our stay in the keys. Truly authentic Italian everything! The food is soooooo delicious and the service is good. I want to try everything on the menu!!! We will definitely be back soon.
… more
… View more
