Isaac’s Restaurant – South York Menu – York, PA

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : York, PA

Deli chain featuring a variety of creative sandwiches, plus wraps, soups & salads. Based on 284 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Isaac's Restaurant - South York 17402

Address:
235 Pauline Drive South York, Plaza, York, PA 17402

Phone: (717) 747-5564

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday 11 AM–8 PM
Sunday 11 AM–8 PM
Monday 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Fresh Green Salads
Ruffled Salad
TeTender mixed greens tomatoes, red onions, carrots, cucumbers, shredded cheese and croutons. Choose a dressing: 1000 Island Dressing, House Made Ranch Dressing, Vinaigrette Dressing, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Balsamic Ranch Dressing, Caesar Dressing, Southwest Ranch Dressing, Honey-Dijon Dressing, Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing, Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing
$5.29
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, red onions, hard-boiled egg, shaved Parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing
$5.29
Ham Sandwiches
Salty Eagle Ham Sandwich
Smoked ham, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomatoes, mustard and pretzel roll. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$9.19
Phoenix Ham Sandwich
Smoked ham, melted provolone, pineapple, mayo and kaiser roll. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$8.39
Chicken Sandwiches
Firebird Chicken Sandwich
Grilled buffalo chicken breast, melted Swiss, red onions, spinach, house-made ranch and pretzel roll. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$9.39
Twisted Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, melted cheddar, spinach, tomatoes, Dijon mustard, mayo pretzel roll. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$9.29
Soups
Isaac’s Famous Pepperjack Tomato Soup $4.59
Bread Bowl With Cheddar Cheese Soup $7.49
Turkey Sandwiches
Scarlet Ibis Turkey Sandwich
Oven-roasted turkey breast. melted muenster, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and french bread. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$8.29
Whooping Crane Turkey Sandwich
Oven-roasted turkey breast, melted Swiss, red onions, spinach, honey-dijon and pretzel roll. Served with Isaac’s Classic Kettle Cooked Chips.Substitute Gluten Free Bread (+ $1.25). Would you prefer a substitution?:
$9.19

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Amelie Gamache
I would love to take the chance to share my horrible experience. When I came into the restaurant I was overwhelmed by the menu and had no idea what to get. I asked a young lady of the name Lauren for help. She was nothing but rude to me. When I first asked her what was good on the menu, she told me, “you have eyes look yourself.” She continuously belittled me and was nothing but rude. I ended up getting a salad. The salad would’ve been good if the service from Lauren was better. I am definitely never coming back and recommend that the company fires her immediately. Never in my life have I been treated like this at a restaurant before.

… more

Liz Von Bargen
We were seated promptly upon walking in to the restaurant around NOON on SATURDAY, and only saw one other table occupied. We began to look at the menus to make our lunch decisions. We sat there for approximately 10-15 minutes while several workers stood around and talked to one another behind the counter, and no one came over to greet us or take our orders. We walked out and went to another restaurant down the street. Don’t think we’ll be back to this one.

… more

mayumi myers-zastowny
My husband and I ate here for lunch recently. It was 11am and just open. It was very clean and fast. I had the salty eagle with broccoli salad and my husband had the mallard. Love the pretzel rolls! Love the complimentary pickles. They are so good! We haven’t been here for a long while but it was good as ever!

… more

Sheri Wolf
Always great food. Love the selections. Perfect for healthier options. Our family loves ordering from here. Great reward program too.

… more

Melissa Leeper
Sandwich was so small for the expensive price!! The server had the personality of a wet dishcloth!! And the place was empty!!

… more

Steve Kaylor
Stopped in for lunch. Good food and great service. Loved the soup!

… more

Christina Valenzuela
It was difficult to enjoy our food due to the lack of A/C on a near 90° day

… more

Jackie Wilson
Yummy food, caring & courteous staff, and pleasant atmosphere.

… more

Peri Olewiler
Zoey was a fantastic waitress. Will be going back 🙂

… more

Leona Halsey
Originally I’d tried placing an order using the web site but was unable to make all of the changes I had wanted to try, so I called in from the parking lot. The gent taking my order was kind and patient while I built my sandwich from the ground up, read it back for accuracy which I greatly appreciated because of the complexity, and offered a side which I thought was polite. I declined and opted for an upgraded side rather than the already fantastic chips. (No drink today.) I was pleased to find he offered a payment over the phone instead of coming in which I jumped at the opportunity. The only hitch in the system was that, while I preferred to use the curbside pickup rather than go in, I was politely asked to use the web to place the order next time since it must go through a different way. He offered to bring my meal out “this time”, and I thanked him several times for it. I wish I could have made the online service work and I’d have been in compliance but appreciated the gesture.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions