I Love NY Pizza Menu – Alpharetta, GA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Alpharetta, GA

Based on 377 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

I Love NY Pizza 30004

Address:
980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta, GA 30004

Phone: (770) 442-9699

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 10 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10 AM–9 PM
Friday 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10 AM–9 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Chicken Strips $8.19
Garlic Knots (2) $2.58
Cheese Bread $6.13
Garlic Bread $6.13
Mozzarella Sticks $8.19
I <3 NY Fries $7.16
Zucchini Sticks $8.19
Salads
Antipasto $14.37
Caesar Salad $10.25
Chef Salad $14.37
Caprese Salad $11.28
Garden Salad $10.25
Greek Salad $11.28
Grilled Chicken Salad $15.40
Cold Sub Sandwiches
Ham & Turkey Sandwich $10.25
Ham Sandwich $9.22
Italian Sandwich $10.25
Salami Sandwich $9.22
Turkey Sandwich $9.22
Hot Sub Sandwiches
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $11.28
Chicken Milanese Sand $11.28
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich $11.28
Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich $11.28
Sausage & Peppers Sanwhich $11.28
Steak & Cheese Sandwinch $11.28
Gyros
Chicken Gyro $10.25
Lamb Gyro $10.25
Calzone
BYO Calzone $10.25
Cheese Calzone $10.25
Ham Calzone $11.28
Meatball Calzone $11.28
Broccoli Calzone $11.28
Pepperoni Calzone $11.28
Spinach Calzone $11.28
Stromboli
BYO Stromboli $10.25
Cheese Steak Stromboli $11.28
Great Westerner Stromboli $11.28
Broccoli Stromboli $11.28
Italian Meatball Stromboli $11.28
Original New York $11.28
Veggie Stromboli $11.28
NY Sausage Stromboli $11.28
Wings
6 Pc Wings $10.25
10 Pc Wings Spec W/ Fries $17.46
12 Pc Wings $18.49
50 Pc Wings $46.60
20 Pc Wings $25.70
All Flat Wings $2.05
All Drums Wings $2.05
Lunch Specials
F- Gyro & Fries $8.23
M- 2 Cheese Slice $8.23
Th- 2 Spec Slices $8.23
Tu- Calzone $9.26
Tu- Stromboli $9.26
WE – Hot Or Cold Sub $9.26
Pasta
Baked Spaghetti $12.31
Baked Ziti Anna Maria $16.43
Baked Ziti Blanco W/ Mushooms $13.34
Baked Ziti Sicilian Eggplant $13.34
Baked Ziti Sicilian $12.31
Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken $16.43
Chicken Francese $14.37
Chicken Marsala $15.40
Veal Parmigiana $13.34
Chicken Parmigiana Pasta $15.40
Eggplant Parm Pasta $14.37
Fettuccine Alfredo $14.37
Eggplant Rollatini Pasta $15.40
Manicotti $10.25
Homemade Meat Lasagna $13.34
Penne Al Vodka $15.40
Ravioli $12.31
Fettuccine Alfredo With Shrimp $15.40
Shrimp Scampi $17.46
Spaghetti $14.37
Spaghetti Meatballs $15.40
Spaghetti Marinara $12.31
Spaghetti Sausage $15.40
Spaghetti Meat Sauce $13.34
Stuffed Shells $10.25
Homemade Veggie Lasagna $11.28
Homemade Baked Ziti $13.34
Ziti $14.37
Ziti Marinara $12.31
Ziti Meatballs $15.40
Ziti Sausage $15.40
Ziti Meat Sauce $13.34
Sides
Extra Sauce $0.77
French Fries $4.07
Homemade Meatballs $7.16
Sausage $7.16
Side Salad $6.13
Side Spaghetti $6.13
Side Ziti $6.13
(Sub group) 1st Half 18”
1st Half Arya Bianca ’18 $0.00
1st Half BBQ Chicken ’18 $0.00
1st Half Buffalo Chicken ’18 $0.00
1st Half Cheese ’18 $0.00
1st Half Deluxe ’18 $0.00
1st Half Eggplant Parm Pizza ’18 $0.00
1st Half Hawaiian ’18 $0.00
1st Half Italian Chicken ’18 $0.00
1st Half Lasagna Pizza ’18 $0.00
1st Half Meat Lovers ’18 $0.00
1st Half NY White ’18 $0.00
1st Half Primavera ’18 $0.00
1st Half Roma Spinach ’18 $0.00
1st Half Sal’s All Meat ’18 $0.00
1st Half Steak & Cheese ’18 $0.00
1st Half The Greek ’18 $0.00
(Subgroup) Margherita
XL-Margherita $22.61
MD-Margherita $17.46
LG- Margherita $19.52
*Lunch Specials
F- Gyro & Fries $8.23
M- 2 Cheese Slice $8.23
WE – Hot Or Cold Sub $9.26
Th- 2 Spec Slices $8.23
Tu- Calzone $9.26
Tu- Stromboli $9.26
20oz Beverages
Bottle Diet Coke $3.35
Bottle Coke $3.35
Bottle Coke Zero $3.35
Can SODA $2.06
Bottle Orange Fanta $3.61
2L Beverages
2L Coke $4.64
2L Sprite $4.64
2L Coke Zero $4.64
2L Diet Coke $4.64
2L Orange Fanta $4.64
Burgers
Mushroom Burger $13.38
Veggie Burger $13.38
Homemade Burger $13.38
Jalapeno Burger $13.38
Desserts
Cannoli $6.17
NY Cheesecake $6.17
Tiramisu $6.17
Game Day Specials
XL Pizza With 1 Topping + 12 Wings + Fries $36.04
2 XL Pizza 1 Top +24 Wings+2 Ord Mozzastick+6 Garlic Kn $66.94
2 LG Pizza With 1 Topping + 24 Wings +Fries $66.94
Half & Half
Half & Half – Medium $13.32
Italian Entrees
Homemade Lasagna (Meat) $7.16
Pizza
NY Cheese $14.94
Sicilian $23.64
Gluten Free Pizza 10” $14.41
Speciality Gluten Free 10” $18.49
MD-Half And Half Pizza $13.32
LG-Half And Half Pizza $19.06
XL-Half And Half Pizza $21.12
Rolls
Spinach Roll $3.61
Pepperoni Roll $3.61
Sausage Roll $3.61
Specialty Pizzas
Three Cheese $17.46
BBQ Chicken $17.46
Buffalo Chicken $17.46
Deluxe $21.58
Eggplant Parmigiana $17.46
Hawaiian $17.46
Italian Chicken $17.46
Lasagna $17.46
Meat Lovers $19.52
NY White $16.43
Margarita Pizza $16.43
Rio Ranch Pizza $19.52
Primavera $18.49
Roma Spinach $18.49
Pepperoni Pizza $18.49
Specialty Pizza $19.52
Steak & Cheese Pizza $18.49
Stuffed Chicken $22.61
Stuffed Meat $23.64
Stuffed Veggie $21.58
The Greek $19.52

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Adrienne Dowd
Completed a pickup order. Got it home and the Food was tolerable. Ordered garlic cheese bread and the cheese was barely melted, bread not remotely toasted. Got 2 small meatballs in a huge container. Pizza order was wrong and barely baked. Definitely will not order again. Stopped getting food from grrr for the same reason a long time ago. They haven’t changed.

… more

Beth Price
We order from this location all the time and normally food is worth the prices which are a bit higher than average. Last night however, I ordered an antipasta salad expecting what I usually get. I think they cut some corners to save money unfortunately at the expense of my order. Their salad lists ham, pepperoni , salami and provolone on the salad. My salad had only ham and it was very noticeable and quite a disappointment from what I normally get. You can’t charge the same amount, skimp on the food and expect people not to notice. I would rather pay more and get what I ordered than have the restaurant skimp and leave things off that are clearly on the menu. And if you are out of ingredients, let your customer know and either charge less or tell them to choose something different. This came across as simply cheating the customer. Do better I love NY Pizza on Birmingham hwy. Very disappointed.

… more

Bronson Kurtz
Pizza was average and got less than stellar service. It smelled good when I went in but it was like they didn’t want me.

… more

yavuz kurt
When I tasted the pizza once in Italy, I still remembered the taste of pizza I ate in Rome, both of them superb delicious. Amo la pizza italiana.. Today I found the same taste .. I LOVE NY pizza

… more

Elizabeth Marcelline
When you call they answer the phone by your name it’s so personal. The pizza is always on time and delicious we love this place.

… more

Dana Tidwell
Ordered deluxe. Delicious pizza in timely manner through uber eats.

… more

Alejandro Gonzalez
I’m originally from Bronx, NY. I’d like to say that I know good pizza when I have it and I Love NY pizza is fantastic pizza. It brings all the good memories of living in NY back to me. I currently live about 8.5 miles from this pizzeria and when I’m in the mood for really good quality pizza, this is where I’ll go. It doesn’t matter to me the drive because the pizza is so good, it’s worth the drive.

… more

C M
I needed a quick lunch, so being in such a great area, Milton, I expected a great experience. I was greeted politely and offered recommendations for the lunch special. When I went to sit down I noticed all the tables were dirty and also the seat. It was after 2 p.m. so it wasn’t busy at all. Only 3 other people were there. The floor was also dirty and I just felt disappointed. I did enjoy my food, a gyro with lamb, garlic knots which were delicious, and fries.

… more

Raul H.
Awesome laid back pizza spot! We actually had a Stromboli and a calzone and they were both absolutely delicious! Customer service was incredible too!

… more

Drew Estey
Undeniable NY style brilliance!! Best pizza in the South.⬅️THAT’S A PERIOD.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions