Snug, unfussy pizza joint serving up large slices, pies & other eats at the counter. Based on 300 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
552 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12206
Phone: (518) 438-7600
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
krystalw68
I wish I could talk about the food but I never got my order , the delivery person left it at the wrong address . A simple phone call could have avoided this , not only did I not get my order I ran across it outside the next day on the step of the apartments next door wasn’t there the day I ordered but magically the next morning it’s there full of ants smh why would you leave someone’s food on the ground especially if we are paying & tipping for DELIVERY not a drop off : hope the next time the driver will contact the customer to say hey I have your order but I’m having trouble finding your place
… more
Jason Bange
Awesome pizza! Super thin, crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese. Buffalo wing was the best!
… more
Georgene Utter
Went to I Love New York pizza website. Wanted a delivery order; press delivery. Placed order, had specific instructions. Order gets dropped off by Door Dash. No where in this process did it indicate DOOR DASH delivery. Order is incorrect. Called I Love New York – where I thought I ordered from- had no record if any delivery to my address. Door Dash has no idea where they picked up the order. NEVER order from this confusing scam. I Love NY pizza central Avenue Colonie!!! You won’t get your order. NO PHONE NUMBER was found during this process!!!
… more
David Hayes
Tried this place for the first time. 12 cut Sicilian was anything but sicilian. Pizza was terrible, hardly any crust at all. It was like just eating cheese and sauce. Highly DO NOT recommend.
… more
Lar ray jay –
Always had good pizza for the price but now that the prices are going up i cant justify the price it used to be the best buy in the city but that comes with inflation pizza has always been a 6.1 but it tasted like an 8. 3 when it used to be cheaper
… more
David Allison
Menu clearly states white house pizza sauce! This clearly has red sauce on it! When I called to say something I was told I was wrong, I made the person on the phone go check google himself! Only then did he apologize for his attitude! He offered to make me another one but at this point I was home and refused to go back out for their mistake! He was apologetic but had no other solution going forward! The pizza is decent, garlic bread looks absolutely nothing like what is pictured and I paid $1 for a pack of Ken’s ranch dressing! If I wanted store bought ranch I had that at home! I will not be going back to this location! I gave 2 stars only because in the end he was apologetic! Hopefully they will get their mistakes fixed and work on their attitude!
… more
Nichole French
Went looking for a good place to eat for pizza the boyfriend and I enjoyed the pizza and the service. If ever back in the area definitely coming back for their slices!
… more
Kay Montgomery
The pizza was hot and cheesy. The service was fast and friendly. I’m coming here every time I’m in Albany!
… more
The Online Hobby Guy
This place used to be really good. You could get a whole pizza and wings for $11 at one point. I went in here a few days ago and paid $20 for 10 boneless wings and a slice of pizza. I wouldn’t be writing this review if the guy wasn’t so rude. I tried to make small talk and he’s just ignores me. On top of that my pizza wasn’t very good and the wings had a stale refrigerator like taste to them. I believe it was the sauce used on them. Not very good at all. Especially for the price I paid.
… more
In my humble opinion
We were passing through Albany and I craved an authentic New York style pizza. Based on their advertisement and reviews, I chose “I Love NY Pizza…” I’m sorry I did. The pizza wasn’t terrible, but it definitely does not live up to the name. I ordered a large cheese pizza and it was doughy, thick and under cooked, the cheese was not completely melted and it was very light on sauce. I wanted some version of a NY street pizza – thin, crispy crust that you have to fold over to eat, just the right balance between cheese and sauce, the grease running down your hand as you eat it… This is not that. Again, not the worst pizza I’ve ever eaten but most definitely NOT New York Pizza. I didn’t even finish the whole thing. As for the service, it was great and fast. But I would have gladly accepted rude and slow if the pizza had lived up to the name and been true New York style. I will look elsewhere if I ever seek pizza in Albany again.
… more
… View more