Based on 159 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
8218 Warren – Sharon Rd, Masury, OH 44438
Phone: (330) 448-8183
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Ann Ridge
Ordered The Big E pizza. Service was quick, personable, and the pizza was very good. It tasted like home. (Chicago). The two gentleman who were working July 1st 2023, God Bless you, it was a very good experience. Thank you.
… more
Edith Patrick
Ignorant person taking calls @ 6:15 7/14/2023. Very rude! I didn’t pick up my order thinking he would SPIT in it!! We come a long way to buy from this family and this man was NOT part of the family owned business. We spent NOTHING and will NOT be back
… more
Mack Shearer
10/10 can’t beat it, try yourself some hilltop today. You won’t regret it. Great tasting pizza and friendly atmosphere.
… more
Alane Jewel
The best pizza around , garlicky and delicious hardy sauce with the best toppings.
… more
William Gerthung
This is my favorite local pizza shop!!! The staff are friendly and always make everything perfect and if for some reason something goes wrong they are always quick to fix it.. The people who run the shop are some of the nicest people!! The food is something really unique and special. When you live around here it becomes a tradition and nothing is better than something that remains the same throughout the years every time I take a bite of the pizza I go back to the first time I ever tried it.. this is a good local family pizza shop who treat their customers like family..If you want some unique pizza that is totally different for dinner And want to order it from somewhere where the staff remembers what u want before u even do u need to go to hilltop pizza.. The prices are more than fair for the kind of quality they offer especially.. words cannot describe how this pizza became my favorite pizza over the years.. all I know is i would be lost without me and my dogs weekly sometimes twice weekly treat.. we love our hilltop and i havent ever met anyone who tried it and hasnt loved it..
… more
Kimberly Anne
We ordered 2 pizzas with extra cheese and the bottom of both of them is Black!!!!! Just not what it used to be….won’t go again!
… more
Garett Tarpenning
We ordered the Carnivore, the Jalapeño Popper and peirogi pizzas and lived them all. The crust is perfect and toppings are plentiful. Great food from a local place.
… more
Carrie Alexander
I grew up with Hilltop Pizza. In over 30 years they are still as yummy as I remember. They are consistent, very fair pricing. The only down side is that they are 30 minutes from my home, the upside to that is that if I lived closer I would be a lot heavier LOL. Would totally recommend them. My husband and our friends are now huge fans of pierogie pizza
… more
Fran Ference
Ordered 4 pizzas for delivery. Because they were making a new batch of dough, we were told it would be delivered in 1 1/2 hours (by 6:30). At 20 to 7 we called and found that the delivery person had car trouble and it would be at least another 45 minutes. We told them we would pick it up instead as it had not yet left the store. We got to the store and found that they had sent it out with the delivery person. They got her back and then tried to charge us $2 more than they had said it would cost. And the delivery person and the person behind the counter were very rude. Finally got it home. We had ordered one w/mushrooms, 2 w/mushrooms & sausage, and 1 with sausage & pepperoni. All 4 were burnt but some edible (according to one of our guests). Instead of 1 with sausage & pepperoni however, we got 1 plain w/burnt cheese on top and I mean the cheese was actually black (this one went in the garbage). 1 mushrooms & sausage had 2 1/2 to 3 inches of dough all around the outside w/sauce, cheese and toppings in a small circle in the center.
… more
Matt Rea
Middle of pizza was still not cooked like raw dough
… more
… View more