Based on 204 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1721 Lake Rd N, Hamlin, NY 14464
Phone: (585) 964-7170
Website: http://hamlinpizzashack.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 3–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Deb Welch
First let me say, I rate this 2 stars because the guys were friendly and personable. That’s about it. I walked in and was dismayed at the grungy and unkempt sought. When dealing with food, that’s NOT what you want to see. Ordered 2 pizzas, one large, one medium. When they came out of the oven, the large was being sliced…… in SQUARES!!!! WHAT!!!???? A round pizza , pizza pie, cut into squares, what universe am I in? Can you fit a square into a round hole, or a round object into a square, I suppose if the round is smaller than the size of the square……but I digress. I politely stopped the young man and asked that he but the remaining half into actual slices. He obliged. Upon bringing them home I was a little happy to have a nice crunch to the crust and a slight chew also, what a pizza dough should be… but there was no flavor to it. The rest of the “pie” was equally disappointing. Too bad, I truly, truly wanted to make this place our pizza go to. Ah well, we search on……
… more
Tia Jolly
We just ordered and said to deliver, they told us on the phone it’d be $48.20. They took over an HOUR and we had to call the make sure they were still making it. The guy came here and said it was $57.60 instead and we ordered a dozen wings which they charged us for and they only gave us 10 but technically only 9 because one of the “wings” is a broken bone with skin on it.
David Knapp
Great place with great food! The owners are great people that care about their food and their customers. They’re hours are very accommodating. Prices are reasonable as is the speed of service. Keep up the great work!
Amanda Vierra
We had to wait an hour and a half for our delivery. When we got our order the pizza was cold and absolutely disgusting. The cheese was rubbery . was told there was 2 drivers.. we literally live 5 min from the place. When I called about my order the manager says ” what do u want me to do about it” and was super cocky and rude like how unprofessional!! Never again!
Jenn Lauler
Absolutely LOVE their pizza. Not a fan of the sheet pizza ‘s dough though but a large …remarkable. best pizza in hamlin!
Toni Garrison
A few of us ordered meatball subs yesterday and the 2 large meatball sub rolls were burnt.The small meatball sub fell on the floor after it was wrapped but wen I got to where I as gonna eat mine , it fell cheese side down becuz I had to try andpeel the cheese off the paper which made a huge mess of a sub to hold and eat but I managed.The burnt ones were a different story.
Joe Heerkens
We have lived in Hamlin just over 2yrs and tonight was the first time we went there for the buffet. There was plenty to choose from and looked delicious and fresh. I’m on keto,so it was wings for me. Let me tell you…they were fantastic and the people were nice. Overall a great atmosphere and experience….
Monsieur Shapeau
Super pizza and wings delivered super fast!! Love these guys
Adam Drawbolt
Great pizza……but on the other hand..the way they cut the extra large pizza!?!?? is not the best way it’s hard to divide up and hard to enjoy when some slices are half the Length of the pizza and some are less than a bites worth they would be the best place around if they looked at the end product and how the customers they serve enjoy the food they make.all tho the food is hot and delicious but they should definitely find a better standard for slices on an extra large pie ♂️ ♂️
Kathleen Crandon
I was drawn into this restaurant by a post on Facebook about a buffet. It was a very reasonably priced buffet with great, fresh options. The staff was very friendly and attentive.
… View more