Based on 110 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4480 E Lake Rd, Hamilton, NY 13346
Phone: (315) 228-2125
Website: http://www.hamiltoninn-ny.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–9 PM |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jennifer Lattimer
Through the year’s we’ve dined here repeatedly. We’ve always had delicious food, amazing cocktails and the service is phenomenal. The last 2 night’s we’ve ordered carry-out and they did not disappoint. We ordered the fried green tomatoes as an appetizer both night’s and they were honestly the most incredible dish we’ve ever had & we pray they stay on the menu.
Peggy Bergen-Pavelka
Upscale cozy and romantic historic place. Inventive dishes and specials.
Vida C
This had been a favorite and perhaps this was an off night but the food was heavy, salty and greasy. The mushroom ravioli was served in a thick, oily cheddar cheese sauce which was almost inedible. (Not what was described on the menu). The calamari was served on top of mashed avocado that was way past its prime, an odd choice of garnish but if you’re going to experiment at least use fresh ingredients.
Stephanie Crain
Beautiful setting, farm to table fare- local ingredients on a lot of the menu. Friendly staff. Delicious.
Carol Reese
Wonderful atmosphere, service and food. So relaxing, reasonable, and our waitress was the best.
Kelly Bigford
The food was excellent I had the special which was salmon with a spacey risotto. The salmon was cooked perfectly. The risotto was the best I have ever had. The chef stopped by our table to check on us. A really warm and friendly place.
Todd Schultze
Great atmosphere with very courteous service. Well prepared dishes with reasonable portions.
t.i. jones
Great place to eat…if you go tell them Ty sent you…guaranteed to be satisfied
Frances Colucci
Had dinner on the front porch which was shaded by several large trees on a hot day. My husband and I had the clams casino and calamari for starters. We shared the pork chop and house salad for our main meal. Plenty for both of us and delicious! Then we shared the flourless chocolate cake which was like a slice of rich chocolate fudge sitting on a bed of this amazing raspberry sauce. It does take a bit longer to get your food but that’s because its made fresh as its ordered and we were aware of that by our server Heather, who did a great job serving us. It was a beautiful evening, great atmosphere and delicious food. Loved spending my birthday dinner there!
Rebekah Mosby
We waited two hours for our first morsel of food. This is not hyperbole. My friend was served soup with no spoon. The server promised to come right back with one and disappeared. Three times, I had to get up and hunt down the manager for basic things. Dessert was disgusting and our server agreed that it was an awful dish (margarita sorbet with giant chunks of salt). We barely touched it, but we paid for it. We received no apologies and no effort was made to make up for this display of incompetence.
… View more