Gyro Jimmy’s Menu – Carle Place, NY

Type : Greek restaurant

Location : Carle Place, NY

Based on 209 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Gyro Jimmy's 11514

Address:
165 Voice Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514

Phone: (516) 279-6481

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Wednesday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Sunday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Monday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Soup
Our Traditional Egg, Lemon Soup Or Lentil
Feta
Drizzled with Olive Oil & Imported Oregano.
$9.00
Halloumi Cypriot Goat Cheese
Grilled & Sprinkled with Imported Oregano.
$10.00
Saganaki Imported Kefalotiri Cheese
Pan Fried & Sprinkled with Imported Oregano.
$10.00
Spanakopita Spinach Pie
Savory Spinach and Feta in a Crispy Phyllo Dough.
$6.00
Tiropita Cheese Pie
Savory Cheese in a Crispy Phyllo Dough.
$6.00
Sauces
Chipotle Mayo-Cup
Chipotle Mayo-Homemade
$2.00
Garlic Cream-Cup
Whipped Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt, EVOO
$2.00
Gyro Jimmy’s Secret Sauce-Cup
It’s a Secret but it is a Mayo based sauce.
$2.00
Tahini-Cup
Sesame Paste, Lime Juice, Vinaigrette, Salt and EVOO.
$2.00
Tirokafteri-Cup
Spicy Greek feta cheese
$2.00
Tzatziki-Cup
Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt and EVOO.
$2.00
Spreads
Hummus
Chickpeas, Tahini, Garlic, Lemon Juice and EVOO.
$7.00
Melitzanosalata
Eggplant Garlic Spread
$7.00
Tzatziki Spread
Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt and EVOO.
$7.00
Tirokafteri
Spicy Whipped Greek Feta Spread.
$7.00
Taramasalata
Whipped Fish Roe Spread.
$7.00
Tasting Trio
Pick Any 3 spreads and enjoy with or Pita Chips!!!
$14.00
Salads
Dakos Cretan Salad
Chopped Tomatoes, Onions, Arahova Feta, Capers. Topped with traditional Cretan Dry Bread (Rusks). Flavored with Herbs & EVOO.
$10.00
Horiatiki (Authentic Greek Salad)
Traditional Greek Villager’s Salad with Arahova Feta, Plum Tomatoes, Cucumber, Onions, Olives & EVOO.
$9.00
Lahano Cabbage Salad
White & red cabbage served with feta in a lemon-EVOO dressing
$9.00
Prasini Chopped Salad
Chopped Lettuce, Dill, Scallions served with EVOO.
$9.00
Plates
Chicken Gyro – Plate
All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
$14.00
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro – Plate
All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin.
$14.00
Pork Gyro – Plate
All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices.
$14.00
Falafel – Plate
Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
$14.00
Grilled Chicken – Plate
All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
$14.00
Meatless Gyro – Plate
House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
$14.00
Sandwiches
Chicken Gyro – Sandwich
All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
$9.00
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro – Sandwich
All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin, in a Pita!
$9.00
Pork Gyro – Sandwich
All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices.
$9.00
Falafel – Sandwich
Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
$9.00
Grilled Chicken – Sandwich
All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
$9.00
Meatless Gyro – Sandwich
House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
$9.00
Skepasti
Chicken Gyro – Skepasti
All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.With Our Tasty Sauce!
$14.00
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro – Skepasti
All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin, in 2 Pitas and our secret sauce!
$14.00
Pork Gyro – Skepasti
All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices- with Our Secret Sauce.
$14.00
Falafel – Skepasti
Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
$14.00
Grilled Chicken – Skepasti
All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
$14.00
Meatless Gyro – Skepasti
House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
$14.00
Sides
Beet Salad
Roasted Red, Crumbled Feta and Walnuts with EVO.
$7.00
French Fries
Fried Potato Wedges with Spices.
$6.00
Garlic Green Beans
Sauteed Green Beans in Garlic & EVO
$6.00
Greek Fries
Fried Potato Wedges with Spices & Feta.
$7.00
Greek Gigantes
Giant Baked butter Beans in a Tomato base with Herbs & Spices.
$6.00
Greek Rice Pilaf
Onions, Garlic, Fresh Lemon Juice and Herbs.
$5.00
Greek Slaw
Cabbage mixed with Fresh Herbs & Spices, EVO & Vinaigrette.
$6.00
Horta
Dandelion Greens with EVO & Fresh Lemon Juice.
$7.00
Lemon Potatoes
Roasted potatoes in lemon, EVO & herbs
$6.00
Pita Bread
Extra Pita Bread
$2.00
Pita Chips
Our Pita Chips
$5.00
Tomato Cucumber
Plump Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cucumbers, Oregano, EVO & Vinaigrette.
$6.00
Soup-Large
Lentil or Egg Lemon Traditional Greek Soup
$6.00
Beverages
Greek Coffee
Greek Coffee-2 Shots of coffee in a cup.
$5.00
Greek Soda
Orange, Lemon-Lime, Sour Cherry (Flavors)
Soda
Coke, Diet Coke, Seltzer or Sprite.
Souroti Greek Sparkling Water
Tuvunu Mountain Tea
Greek Ice Mountain Tea with Honey and Lemon.
$5.00
Water
Desserts
Baklava
Walnuts & Honey in Philo Dough with Honey.
Galactobouriko
Greek Custard and Honey Cake.
Greek Rice Pudding $5.00
Greek Yogurt Parfait
Yogurt with Oats and Honey.
$6.00
Coffee
Frappe
Greek Ice Coffee.
$5.00
Fredo Espresso $5.00
Regular / Decaf Coffee $2.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Katy Xu
Very fresh and good portions of meat. We both got the platter, which comes with a protein, two sides, and a sauce. I was going to ask for tzatziki anyways, but they didn’t ask which kind. Make sure to specify if you want something else. Dinner rush came with a lot of online orders, with only a few staff to manage everything. However, food was great and came out rather quick. I would come back again.

Shyraaz Safi
Was in the neighborhood and this restaurant came up. Very simple and homey feel, clean and easy to order from. Went here to try the food for the first time. Ordered Chicken Souvlaki – Skepasti which came with fries. Started off with the lentils soup which I would highly recommend it’s very tasty and nutritious. The Skepasti is layered with chicken and lettuce and sauce it’s really good. It reminds me of a gyro but as a sandwich. Also tried their stuffed grape leaves which were great definitely recommend. Will most likely visit again when in the area. The portions size are big and would advise you can share certain platters.

Amanda Ortiz
This was our 2nd time eating here. Giving them 5 stars is a pretty easy decision. The food is delicious. What really sets it apart was the sides. Beets with feta and walnuts, butter beans in tomato sauce. What other place is giving you both of those options with a gyro for 17 dollars? The service is friendly and they clearly stay on top of cleaning the dining area. My only complaint is that I want to a location closer to my house.

Ms. Dee
Clean, excellent customer service, fresh chicken, fresh veggies, and the tzatziki sauce is exceptional. My only complaint is that the food in my gyro was not evenly spread out. The meat was on one end, and the sauce was on the other end. When I bit into it, there was meat but no sauce. I will come here again.

Lucy sanchez
Seriously the best Greek food! I can’t say enough about this place. Staff is friendly, restaurant is very clean, and the food 10 stars! I had the chicken souvlaki hubby had the gyro. Great portions and the sides yum! we both had the beet salad and it didn’t disappoint. I live 30 minutes away and am already planning my return trip. Thank you for a wonderful dinner

Evelna
I had high hopes from all the great reviews and I really wanted to love it. But it’s just okay for me.

Refat K
Decided to try this restaurant as it was nearby. The chicken lunch special was a hit with my kid as it was juicy and not dry. A must try if you’re in the neighborhood.

dora fortuna
Editing my review based on my latest visit. We came right after they opened around 12.30 and they gave us fries that were old and dry… why would you give fries day(s) old when you are just starting the day? Puaj. We also ordered the chicken souvlaki which is way worse than the pork. So … if you go for the pork and not when they open… you should be fine!

Linda DaRocha
Wow! Talk about flavor! Went Sunday night for dine in dinner. The food was fantastic! Chicken gyro plate with lemon potatoes and the slaw. Fresh and generous portions. Then the beet and feta salad with walnuts was so refreshing! If I could have tried everything, I would have. Went back today for the 3 dip plate and cabbage salad. Also had a sampling of the lentil soup. Definitely the best Greek food I’ve had. Lest I forget the baklava. Impeccable! The right amount of crunch, honey and spice. The owner and his team are extremely personable and gracious to their guests. Yes, I will rerun this week for more!

Luke Carlson
Some of the best customer service you’ll ever have. The food is extremely delicious. You can taste how fresh the ingredients are. The restaurant is very clean. Will be back.

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

×
Photo Image