Based on 232 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
7425 W Peoria Ave #100, Peoria, AZ 85345
Phone: (623) 878-3000
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Necie Williams
I ordered pizza and wings at your location on 75th Ave and Peoria. The wings we raw as seen in the photo and the pizza was gross. The sausage was not cooked well and taste old and moldy. I wouldn’t recommend this place at all. I contacted the place and was not able to speak to the manager. Was told by the young lady that answered the phone that they could replace my order. If you gave me raw and moldy food, why would I want you to replace my order. I will never order from this place again.
… more
K H
Tried this place for the first time. The stromboli looked like it had been run over! Flat as a pancake, with 1 row of pepperoni slices & very little cheese, nothing else but dough that stuck together because it was so flat. Dough is all I taste. Took pictures before throwing food & $$ down the drain. The seasoned fries had seasoning only on a few of the top fries. They weren’t even cooked. So out of a salad, stromboli & seasoned fry order, the salad was the only thing edible but I ordered an antipasto & definitely not an antipasto. When I went to eat the salad, I realized they didn’t send the dressing!!!! Wasted money & time. It took a long time to even get the food. I DO NOT RECOMMEND GUS’S NEW YORK PIZZA!!!!
… more
Megan Furrey
We ordered here tonight through Uber eats. I ordered 1 chicken Alfredo and 1 build your own. We received 2 chicken Alfredos. On Uber eats it says grilled chicken and it seemed like the chicken that was put on it were just boneless chicken wings. The portions were VERY VERY small for being $24 a piece. The Alfredo sauce is very bland and tastes like out of a jar and some how they managed to burn some of the noodles. I paid nearly $100 for some of the worst food I have had in awhile. We will never order there again.
… more
Andrea Roberts
I currently have slices in the oven to finish cooking to try and salvage 2 pizzas at over $40. This was our go to every month. What happened? Pepperoni pizza has about a dozen on it.
… more
Isabel Bixler
We ordered from Gus’s New york Pizza through door dash and it was awful. We just moved to the area and wanted to try some new places so we decided to try Gus’s. We ordered the supreme pizza, the appitizer sampler, and the strawberry cheese cake. The pizza was not the best tasting pizza with the crust tasting old, and the sampler was ok but the tenders in the sampler were burnt. The cheese cake was soggy not a decent size for $4.99 and it wasn’t even stawberry. We decided to call the resturant and let them know we did not get the right cheesecake. They then told us they were out of all of their flavored cheesecakes and no one had tried to reach out to us to let us know. We also told them the cheesecake was soggy and they mostly blew us off and said that doesn’t usually happen. Would not waste your money here.
… more
R E (Chefboi-RE)
Great food… my go to pizza shop ever since that chef left 4months ago, and that young kitchen manager started upgrading the food, best spot in AZ
… more
Zack Nani
Reubin , was amazing . Food was excellent, And his service was top of the line. I am the manager of the grand express Carwash. Gus’s pizza worked with me to make sure I had food for my corporate event ! He did an amazing job and everyone was talking about food . Highly recommended!
… more
Lólaidh Mac
Ordered a pizza and it came without mushrooms and it was suppose to be cauliflower crust which it wasn’t and that made it so I couldn’t eat it. They were absolutely not helpful at all when I contacted them to try and get a refund for the extras I paid for and didn’t receive. My niece also said her pep and cheese pizza was disgusting and she didn’t even finish a slice. Utterly dissatisfied and disappointed!
… more
Victor Barrio
Straight trash! An hour and half to get a sandwich and fries, didn’t get my side of ranch. I decided to use door dash cause I had issues with their delivery before. I called just to pick to up myself but of course got a run around. Every time something goes wrong there they promise everything will be fresh, soggy fries soggier sandwich. Last time I ever come here and will tell people to go elsewhere
… more
Ceci C
so friendly here, the food is amazing. BEST WINGS hands down! Crispy & well cooked! Doesn’t get any BETTER! PPG!
… more
… View more