Based on 39 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
417 S Main St, Sheridan, IN 46069
Phone: (317) 804-7778
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Reviews
Connie Deason
So happy to have this quality pizza /Italian place in Sheridan. Great sauce with the perfect sweetness! Everything is clean, prompt, tasty and the staff is wonderful!
… more
Chris Leonard
Hello. Overall a good pizza place. Two complaints. First we had to wait in line for 10-20 minutes to pickup our called in order. Got a text saying it was ready, but a long line in front of us had us waiting while our pizza was getting cold. Not sure why it took so long? But while waiting we noticed just how loud it was in there. They were busy but not that busy. There’s virtually no soft surfaces so sounds just bounce around. The owners did a great job of designing a interesting place but missed some important things. We wouldn’t go there to dine out you’ll end up yelling at each other. The pizza was very good though.
… more
Pam Harris
I got a Herb Italian sandwich and hardly no pepperoni and baked ham and my husband got a baked ham and same thing thing hardly no meat, it was mostly bread. We ate their before and it has been great. I was just disappointed in the sandwiches. If I was eating at the restaurant I was sent them back. We will be back.
… more
Nichole Suiters
I am glad to have a dine-in option in Sheridan that I can take my family to.
… more
Jacob Thifault
Awesome location! Normally go to Westfield, but now that Sheridans location is open I’ll be a much more frequent flyer.
… more
Rebecca Bryant
First time ordering from Greeks in Sheridan. We used to have Greeks in Kirklin, but it went under. I ordered a 16 in pizza; half double pepperoni; half double sausage w extra cheese; and an order of breadsticks. Breadsticks were perfect. The double sausage w extra cheese half of the pIzza was phenomenal. The double pepperoni half had no pepperoni. When i phoned in the order, it was very noisy in the background, so maybe that accounts for the missed pepperoni….
… more
B C
Called about ordering a pizza they offer pickup or delivery, says no delivery online Google. So I ask how far is your delivery radius she goes ” I’m not sure” I say it’s about 4.7 miles and she’s like oh no that’s way too far, I call Westfield Greeks very nice young lady who knew immediately how far they could deliver and took my order promptly and delivered quick. Sheridan definitely needs some training or have someone answering the phone who knows the gist of things. Westfield for the win!
… more
Mike Jones
Greeks is good option but hardly ever have delivery service. Who doesn’t have delivery on the weekends? They definitely don’t have online ordering as they claim hopefully they get it together will be my last time trying to order their food.
… more
Chris Roberts
New building looks fantastic. Plenty of space and a bar with tvs makes for a fun atmosphere. Service was timely and food was great. Western pizza was my favorite. Welcome to Sheridan!
… more
Emily Bookout
My husband and I just went up there to eat tonight. Y’all….. don’t sleep on Greeks now!!! the breadsticks and cheese…AMAZING… the rafaels chicken barbecue pizza …AMAZING! this place is much needed in sheridan. So beautiful and inviting inside! Also the ingredients were very fresh and food came out perfect and hot! definitely an upgrade for our little town
… more
… View more