Located in Old Downtown, our pizza shop is one of the best in the area. We specialize in serving stone baked, old world style pizza. Our restaurant also offers Chicago style deep dish pizza, gluten free pizza, and delicious subs. Call (614) 875-0938 for delivery or for information about our catering options.
Informal Italian option dishes out a variety of familiar pies, subs & stromboli in a simple setting. Based on 274 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4034 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone: (614) 875-0938
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eric Hauter
It seems like no one is ever here, but this place has the best pizza in Grove City. Try the super cheese thing, it’s amazing. Huge slices, great toppings, fast service. Good salads too.
… more
Justin Jenny
This pizza sauce was good, not plain but had a hint of sweetness. The crust at the end of the slice was tasty. The downfall of the pizza was it was fairly greasy and caused the slice to droop. Three out of five pepperoni score from Justin and Jenny!
… more
Melinda Thompson
We have ordered from here for at least and year or so. Last night we ordered 2 large pizzas, and it was so nasty. Very disappointed. Not sure if we will order from here again.
… more
Jayden Dunigan
My experience here was incredibly disappointing. The pizza was uncooked, the food lacked flavor, and the staff was unprofessional. Lady wouldn’t even get off her phone playing a video game for even a minute to help us out. I would not recommend here at all. Will not be back.
… more
Jim Weaver
The Old World Pepperoni pizza was absolutely delicious! We had great service as well!
… more
Tiffany Spangler
We love walking through Downtown Grove City and stopping in to have lunch.
… more
Shae Hash
They have roaches, cancelled our order and walked out. We saw a baby roach on the floor, that means there is definitely more.
… more
Chad Fields
It was OK, that’s about it. To call what I ordered a “deep dish” pizza should be criminal though. I’ve had deeper dished handtossed pizzas than what I was given. Tons of places with equal quality and way less money out there. I’m not trying to trash the place but when you spend upwards of 30 bucks for DEEP DISH pizzas that’s kinda what you expect.
… more
Mark B.
Pretty average pizza and subs. It wasn’t terrible but nothing special either. I probably wouldn’t come back.
… more
Jim Ford
Part ii: the pizza was FANTASTIC! I had been there before. Even my mom enjoyed the pizza – I was worried she wouldn’t like it. I got a small salad to share. When they brought it out, I told myself, ut oh – should have gotten a large salad. But, there was plenty of salad for the both of us. I got the 10″, hand tossed The Works (no hot peppers, please; thank you). It was really good! I hope their work force gets back to where it needs to be for them to resume normal operations. It was well worth the drive from the far west side of Columbus. Yes…I know: such a long drive! 😉
… more
… View more