Grandma Penny’s Pizza, a Fort Myers pizza restaurant offers a truly Italian experience using centuries-old techniques and authentic handmade ingredients! Offering NY Style Brick Oven Pizzas, Pasta Dinners, Fresh Subs, Salads, Calzones, Stromboli, Beer, Wine, and more!
Located at the former Amore Brick Oven Pizza location, we serve oven-fresh creations brimming with the cheesy and tangy goodness people have come to love, plus a few more flavors to spice things up! Our signature pizza sauce, which we have perfected using the finest ingredients and spices, is sure to add delight to every diner’s pizza experience.
Based on 370 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4353 Hancock Bridge Pkwy, North Fort Myers, FL 33903
Phone: (239) 217-0584
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 3–8 PM |
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Charles Barbera
This was my first time ordering here and I had a mixed experience. Our take out order was ready on time and was correct except for our pizza which we requested a substitute of banana peppers in place of green peppers and still recieved green peppers. The meatballs I ordered were also still a little cold. I warmed the meatballs in the oven and my wife notified the resteraunt about the mistake on our pizza. They promptly replaced it with a correct pizza via delivery which was greatly appreciated however the new pizza was extremely undercooked. I understand the desire to get a new pizza to us quickly but not at the expense of quality. I would have gladly waited a few more minutes for a consistent finished product. The final pizza we received was a floppy mess, luckily the oven was still warm from the meatballs and we were able to finish cooking it. I gave them 4 stars for trying to make it right but they really dropped the ball when they could have easily knocked it out of the park.
… more
Steven Salisbury
I ordered here for delivery for the first time in years today. We got a meat lovers 16″, Buffalo chicken 16″ and a pepperoni calzone. All the food was so great, I couldn’t imagine it being any better. Not sure what the owners background is but it seems like a “Brooklyn style” of pizza and it was some of the best I have had in the area.
… more
Alissa Barshinger
Delicious pizza and homemade Italian bread at a family-owned restaurant. Had a really lovely dinner here! Pizza was a perfect combo of crispy crust and delicious toppings. Bread was amazing with a soft crumb and slightly crispy crust. Staff were super nice and nearly everyone is a part of the owner’s family. It’s awesome to support a family business, and you will LOVE the food! I only took one pic bc it was sooo good we didn’t want to wait to eat!
… more
Todd Sander
I rarely leave reviews however I felt this place deserved one. We ordered delivery and it showed up before the quoted time. Everything was hot and fresh! We got 2 pizzas, wings and garlic knots. The food was delicious!! Pizzas were thin and perfect. The wings were crispy and tender. The garlic knots were the best I’ve ever tasted in my entire life! So fresh, soft, buttery and lots of garlic!! Thank you for the amazing food!
… more
Bob C
This little pizza parlor has a lot of pluck. Opening off-season , they have pushed through some challenging times -always upbeat. Always performing well. A recent visit shows the community is recognizing how well they do. They’re getting busy!The staff provides excellent service and the food is good. The sit down dining room is comfortable and stylish. A nice place to step out and grab dinner.
… more
Zinnia Torres
Omg do they know their pizza best NY style yet!! And let me tell you if your looking for Gluten Friendly options they are a great go to!! Absolutely fresh ingredients with the most friendly service…they make you feel like family!! Bonus Jessica is a serious pleasure and makes your dining experience even better! Try the goat cheese TO DIE FOR!!
… more
Chelsie Reyes
Ordered a greek salad, wings, and the margherita pizza and everything was so good! Staff was super friendly & helpful. I don’t leave reviews often, but they deserve it!
… more
Corey Dalton
Service was on point. Highly recommend the supreme pizza, the Antipasto salad and tiramisu. Delicious and reasonable. Will be back again soon.
… more
Fallan Terilla
If you are looking for a great meal at a family owned local restaurant, you have found it!! We ordered the special that day, spinach ravioli. Wow. Delicious. The alfredo sauce was perfect not too thick, great flavor and the ravioli were amazing. We also tried the kale sausage soup. Great flavor, a lot of bits of sausage! Another home run! This will be a regular stop for us now!
… more
Daniel Fay
This is one of the best pizza places I have ever been to! Garlic Knots and Pepperoni rolls are amazing! Great people!
… more
… View more