Based on 287 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
124 N Broadway, Coweta, OK 74429
Phone: (918) 279-0630
Website: http://www.goodfellapizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ashley Nowak
I don’t think the Sunday staff is thrilled to be there. Everytime we’ve ordered pizza it has been so good, like the absolute best. We ordered it tonight and it was sauceless and chewy, just a big jump in the wrong direction, and they didn’t even give us the full order of mozz sticks that we paid for
… more
Robert Gordon
Received order no fork for salad to eat with nothing but lettuce little cheese and croutons. Ask for napkins none. Have to say pizza was good. Need to Change prices on their page they are not correct. Their delivery service is poor
… more
Heather Hampton
My husband ordered a salad with French dressing at lunch and it came out with Ranch. He sent it back and when it came out the next time significantly later it came with a side cup of what was supposed to be French-it was slightly off color and very runny. He put it on his salad giving it the benefit of the doubt and took a bite….it was HOT SAUCE. His mouth was on fire and not even a “I am sorry about that” came from the waitress. I called twice that evening to speak with a manager and both times I was told they were not in and didn’t know when. I called about 3 hours apart on each call. This place has always been very good with service and food in the past. I do feel however that this was not a mistake….they knew what they were doing. This could have seriously hurt someone especially an elderly or small child.
… more
Alac Diesel
Wonderful pizza. We tried the large chicken bacon ranch pizza and a small cheesestick. Portions were good and taste and quality were great. Tastes like real ingredients. Will be our go-to place for pizza. Ready to try the subs and salad.
… more
Gary McGee
I dined in there yesterday and was greeted promptly, and my family and I have gone there on multiple occasions. Their service is great and so is their food. Their menu items are all moderately priced.
… more
Scott Keele
Just like everyone says. Super friendly staff. Free refills (who needs to even say that anymore?). And really good pizza. I loved the crust… but would recommend using fresh mushrooms instead of mushrooms out of a jar… Would I go back? Absolutely!
… more
Dustin Nuttall
After living in NYC for 2 years ruined pizza everywhere for me and last 4 years living in Montana, the pizza was the worst I’ve ever had. So I tried the calzone tonight and it’s absolutely terrific! The delivery driver was very fast, about half the time they told me it would take and very kind. I’m very pleased with my purchase and this will now be my #1 place for pizza now!
… more
Adam Bailey
It’s one of my favorite pizza places when I’m down here at my Lakehouse, might order it again tonight
… more
Taylor Lee
This is not the experience if you have any other option, the front staff is rude and will just stare at you while you wait for your pizza, have tried it more than once and never had a good experience with customer service.
… more
Liz Mac
Love the “BOSS” pizza. Best around, our favorite. So glad to be able to support a home town business.
… more
… View more