Based on 264 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1118 Stitt St, Wabash, IN 46992
Phone: (260) 569-1162
Website: http://goodfellasofwabash.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bianca Sedano
Absolutely outstanding food. Best pasta I’ve ever had, best pizza sauce and by far the best breadsticks/cheesy garlic bread. My husband and I have found our new favorite spot to eat. Great food, great people, great place!
… more
B M
We just tried their pizza for the first time a few weeks back. We really like it. Great value for the price. Check their website for good specials. I believe they have them for every day of the week. We are definitely going to be buying from them again (and have been since our first visit). I highly recommend you give them a try.
… more
Cheryl Meyer
They are awesome to work with! Had a lunch for our volunteers at work and asked for lunch to be delivered at 11:00, they did everything they could to have the lunch delivered at that time even though it was probably a little early for them. The lunch was delivered just before 11:00, hot and so good!
… more
Chad Hawley
Service was friendly. Dining area is clean, but small! Five tables maybe. The food was great! Huge breadsticks, good garlic cheese bread, and great pizza. I especially love the jarred mushrooms on the pizza. Took me back to when we made pizza at home as a kid. This is where I want to eat in Wabash from now on. Rare 5 star from me on food!
… more
adam gillum
The wings here used to be amazing. This time when I called, I was on hold for twenty minutes and then the young girl that answered was rude. When I got my wings home, several of them I couldn’t bite through and when I did get through them, they were completely raw and bloody. Worst service I’ve ever had.
… more
Kate Violette
It’s been a decade since I’ve had this pizza, and I was a bit bummed when it wasn’t how I remembered. Still delicious for sure, but not what I was hoping for. The female who took my order over the phone wasn’t super pleasant and our interaction when I picked up my order felt strained. I think I’m also biased about the square cut… I very much dislike flabby pizza. I can appreciate having an original pizza place in town! The theme is great! Next time, I’ll order my pie well done!
… more
Leona Grier
Tried the “Hitman” I ordered a pan crust pizza. The pizza was thin except for the edges, no flavor, soggy and kinda burnt. When the delivery driver forgot my soda I called and ask if he could bring back taco sauce, management said she doesn’t enforce giving it out. The “Hitman” pizza is a taco pizza. For the price of $38.00 including breadsticks,I should’ve taken my business elsewhere
… more
Kane Stepnowski
Breadsticks are FANOMANAL. Not too much butter, little salt and pepper, and that crunchy crust with the hot, fluffy, moist center. Decently sure they’re handmade in the store, no frozen doughs here. I ordered then with The Mafia pizza, and its ingredients lead one to believe it’s a cheeseburger pizza, and let me tell you, it tastes EXACTLY like a cheeseburger. I’ve had their shrimp ravioli as well… It was all delicious. The staff was more than friendly. If you want a great plate of food, with a close-knit community feel, in a nice mom and pop shop, this is where you go.
… more
Dan G
No fuss pizza place. Fast, extremely friendly service. They have some gluten free pizza options as well!
… more
Moine Martin
First time eating here and it was absolutely delicious. The pizza is amazing. Very reasonably priced. You can tell they put their customers first and the employees put their heart and soul into making delicious food. We will be back. Goodfella’s Pizza for the win!!
… more
… View more