Goodfella’s Pizza Menu – Henryville, IN

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Henryville, IN

Based on 619 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Goodfella's Pizza 47126

Address:
103 Colonels Way, Henryville, IN 47126

Phone: (812) 294-3343

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 7 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 7 AM–10 PM

Menu

FOOD
10″ Pizza $9.50
14″ Pizza $13.50
16″ Pizza $14.50
Meatball $8.50
Grilled Chicken Grinder $8.50
Honey Mustard Chicken $8.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch $8.50
Stromboli $8.50
Veggie Sub $8.50
Philly Steak $8.50
Pork Tenderloin $8.50
Ham-N-Cheese $8.50
Steak Hoagie $8.50
Italian $8.50
Slider $2.00
Hamburger $5.50
Cheeseburger $6.00
Bacon Cheeseburger $7.00
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger $7.00
Mushroom Swiss Burger $7.00
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $6.00
Club Sandwich $8.00
Fish Sandwich $8.50
Baked Spaghetti $9.00
Chicken Alfredo $9.00
5 Tenders & FF $9.50
8 Bone In Hot Wings $8.00
16 Bone In Hot Wings $16.00
24 Bone In Hot Wings $24.00
Boneless Wings 1/2 Pound $7.00
Boneless Wings Pound $14.00
Boneless Wings 2 Pound $26.00
Cheese Bread $8.00
Bread Sticks $6.00
Pretzel Sticks $5.00
Jalapeno Poppers $5.00
Onion Petals $4.00
Loaded Cheese Fries $5.00
Mozzarella Sticks $5.00
Fried Cauliflower $4.00
Fried Mushrooms $4.00
Fried Pickles $4.00
Corn Nuggets $4.00
Onion Rings 8 To An Order $4.00
Cheese Curds $4.00
House Salad $4.00
Chef Salad $10.00
Grilled Chicken Salad $10.00
Calzone $11.00
Fries-Separate Box $2.00
Add Bacon And Cheese To Fries $2.09
Cottage Cheese $2.09
2 Slices Of Bread $0.99
Side Of Grilled Chicken $4.00
4 Meatballs W/Sauce $4.00
4 Mtballs With X&C $4.99
Marinara $0.75
Pepperocinis $0.75
Crushed Red Pepper $0.75
Parmasean Cheese $0.75
Bag Of Chips $1.00
Garlic Bread $1.00
Ketchup $0.00
Tater Tots-Separate Box $2.00
2 Tend & FF Kids $4.50
Mini Burger & FF Kids $4.50
Grilled Ham & Cheese & FF $4.50
Grilled Cheese & FF Kids $4.50
Personal Pan Kids $4.50
Kids Spaghetti (Sauce & Noodles Only) $4.00
Apple Cinnamon Dessert Pizza $8.00
Oreo Dessert Pizza $8.00
Cinna – Stix $6.00
Half Apple/Half Cherry Pizza $8.00
Cherry Dessert Pizza $8.00
Extra Sauce Options $0.00
DRINKS
Coke 2lt $3.00
Diet Coke 2lt $3.00
Sprite 2lt $3.00
20 Oz Coke $2.00
20 Oz Diet Coke $2.00
20 Oz Sprite $2.00
Coke Zero $2.00
20 Oz Cherry Coke $2.00
20 Mr Pibb $2.00
Gold Peak Tea 18.5oz $2.00
20 Oz Fanta $2.00
20 Oz Dasani Water $2.00
Minute Maid Orange Juice $2.00
Minute Maid Apple Juice $2.00
20 Oz Mello Yello $2.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Tiffany O’Leary
Couldn’t ask for better service today! Ordered their special and it was on point!! It was done early and delicious. We generally go for their breakfast buffet, but I thought I would try their lunch and I have been missing out!

… more

sharon hubbard
We ordered a thin crust extra large worx pizza . When I picked it up I thought the box was empty. Crust was burnt up and was certainly not the works. Disappointed because we have been there many times but this time was awful.

… more

Chloe Turner
third time there for the weekend breakfast buffet. i highly recommend. good home country feel. friendly efficient service. food good. some beverages included in with the buffet price. great price for the buffet. great scrambled eggs. plenty of meats, fruit and pastries.

… more

Kathy Meuninck
This is a fun place to eat. Staff is very cordial and engaged with the patrons. Always welcome you. The food is great for a very reasonable price. Never disappointed when I go there. The pizza is very good and the deserts are worth every bite.

… more

Troy Haas
Pizza tasted fine. But it was all bread I got a small pepperoni pizza and it had maybe 5 pepperonis total on the whole pizza. Just real skimpy. I paid 12 bucks for baked bread with some sauce on it. The last time I got pizza here it was really good. Maybe just having a bad day.

… more

Elizabeth Rayburn
We went for the weekend breakfast buffet and everything was great! There were eggs, various types of sausage, bacon, hashbrowns, pancakes, french toast sticks, biscuits & gravy, and a great fruit selection. I’m sure there were some more items I’m forgetting. The price was also very reasonable.

… more

Yakky Doodle
A great little small town restaurant that provides excellent service when dining in or receiving delivery. The food is tasty and my delivered pizzas are always hot and on time. I have only dined in once…the restaurant is small and very muched loved by those in Henryville…so it stays pretty crowded and seating is tight. The staff are always warm and friendly…they actually greet you with a smile and ask how you are…that is amazing customer service!

… more

The Traveling Man
Went in today around 12 Noon for the Pizza Buffet. It tasted as if it had been out for hours but they hadn’t been open that long. The pizza and breadsticks were not good. The dessert pizza was ok, nothing special. There was only 1 waitress so she was staying busy. I doubt I come back considering all the better pizza places just South of here in Sellersburg and New Albany.

… more

Jason Pritchard
We ate the Saturday morning buffet. Food was pretty good. It was all piled up at the buffet table. Biscuits were a little well done, but over all would recommend.

… more

Angie Frazier
Small dining space, but well worth the 10-minute wait! We took advantage of the Sunday all-you-can-eat breakfast buffet, which was only $10.50, including drink. All the locals eat here, so you know it’s good. Lots of options, too, including bacon, different types of sausages, pancakes, biscuits and gravy, country fried steak, hasbrown casserole, eggs (made to order if requested), pastries, and fruit. Although they were busy, service was great; friendly staff and homey atmosphere. We are looking forward to trying their Monday thru Friday daily pizza and salad buffet. On Fridays, they have an extended selection including Salisbury steak, chicken livers, and plenty home-cooked sides. I recommend everyone give it a try!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions