Bagels, smoked fish & sandwiches are served for breakfast & lunch in basic surrounds. Based on 288 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
100 Pantigo Pl, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: (631) 329-8300
Website: https://website-6789151241031609186142-bagelshop.business.site/?m=true
Hours
Tuesday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Wednesday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Thursday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Friday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Saturday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Sunday | 6 AM–3 PM |
Monday | 6 AM–4 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Derek Snyder
Bagels are still excellent but they are increasingly getting orders wrong. Got to the beach only to discover my bacon egg and cheese on everything bagel was on a roll instead. This kind of thing is happening a lot these days. You guys aren’t handcrafting Ferraris here, maybe visit a Subway or Chipotle and learn about the benefits of the assembly line…
… more
John Hinnegan
Cannot get an order correct.
… more
nysoleil _F
The good: bagels are good
… more
Nathan Loyer
Only had the bagels and they are excellent, cream cheese is good. The interior design is ok/functional. Took us 5 minutes to be served.
… more
C’mecca Campbell
Simple. Savoury. Specialties.
… more
Daren Frankel
Ordered the famous fish platter for catering and had an Uber delivery driver pick up and deliver on my behalf. The staff was super helpful in arranging and the recipient was super pleased with the quality and quantity of what they received.
… more
Mary Bquick
Good bagels, but the lines are long ..I waited over 10 minutes in line today just to place an order, and after I placed the order, the person who took my order also took about 4 other orders. So now I’m waiting for her to complete all 5 orders before I get my bagel and cream cheese. A total of 15-20 minutes… There has to be a better way.
… more
Gabriela Schwed
Worst customer service ever! Took forever for them to take my order and then they forgot to make it. I asked one person about it and she didn’t say anything and walked away. How is this place still in business?
… more
Amanda Miller
Not the friendliest staff, but we enjoyed the spicy hobo and regular hobo. Good coffee. Out of plain bagels, so we branched out and tried the garlic bagels and were glad of it. We both would have preferred some cream cheese to the hashbrown, but who are we to suggest a change to a staple? Napkins are the size and thickness of single-ply tissue. We made more of a mess trying to use them than if we’d wiped our mouths on our sleeves.
… more
G
Delicious bagels! Best in the Hamptons by far. Friendly staff. Lines look long but move extremely fast. Menu has a wide variety of sandwiches. Easy parking and a great location.
… more
… View more