Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering calzones, sides & desserts. Based on 23 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
100 Crossroads Dr, Sheldon, IA 51201
Phone: (712) 631-4444
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Reviews
Scott Jensen
I’m not one to complain very often at all, but this needs to be said. I went and got three chicken thighs tonight. They were awful and so incredibly overdone. I couldn’t chew the skin or the meat. Spit it out on my plate. And thighs are usually always very tender. I will be hard-pressed to buy from there again I am sorry to say. It was a complete waste of money. I truly hope things get straightened out because otherwise, we have been happy with Godfathers food.
… more
Brenda Krogman
Drove to Sheldon to get a pizza. It was 1/2 all meat and 1/2 taco….Got home and there was no toppings on the taco…called them and staff said I don’t know what to do because there isn’t no managers here..they did take my name and phone number but haven’t heard anything…needless to say I won’t be making a trip back there again…
… more
Jayd Soule
The pizza is very good!! My two favorites are either the all meat combo or the bacon cheeseburger with no onions and pickles. I haven’t had a bad experience with this location yet. Kinda sad that they only offer golden crust or thin. I miss their original crust that they had. Also the potato wedges are awesome! Happy to have Godfathers back in Sheldon! So now I don’t have to go to Cherokee or LeMars for GodFathers!! I missed having that option instead of just Pizza Ranch or Casey’s. Keep up the good work.
… more
Pat Verrips
One of the best pizzas that we have ever gotten from anywhere. It couldn’t have been any fresher and warmer than it was. Will definitely order from there again!!
… more
Isaac Mino (Pickle Rick)
What cause u hot pizza at a gas station ur a pizza place. Nice try godfathers but it ain’t godfathers pizza that I ever remember eating
… more
Robert Selbitschka
The morning staff are great. They got me my gas even before they technically opened and were so polite.
… more
Brad Franken
Good chicken and pizza. Good dinner specials.
… more
Anita Heitritter
Great pizza and chicken!!
… more
Laura Drews
Yummy
… more
John Bowman
Great
… more
… View more