GJP Italian Eatery is your independent choice for high quality pizza, Italian food and handmade subs! We also offer award winning wings, salads and a wide variety of Upstate NY favorites. We pride ourselves on being a part of the community and are constantly involved in enriching the lives of local children, adults with special needs and those who less fortunate.
Based on 235 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
140 NY 104, Oswego, NY 13126
Phone: (315) 207-1000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Reviews
AngryGoat 6.0
Stopped In for a quick lunch with a couple people. It was after 1:00 and somewhat busy. The restaurant was clean and the workers friendly.
Naomi White
We waited over an hour an a half for a pizza we were told would be ready in 25 minutes. When we got it it was cold. Not just a little cool, but completely cold. We will never return as this has happened several times to me at this location. I once waited over 2 hours. Do not go here !!!
Helene Metcalf
We had GJP cater our graduation party. Larry made it super easy from the beginning. He talked me through different choices of the menu. He delivered and set up food. The food was amazing! We ordered pulled pork, bbq chicken thighs, baked ziti and meatballs and a variety of side salads . Everything was delicious! So many compliments throughout the day! I highly recommend GJP for all of your catering needs.
David Hamilton
The meat lovers pizza is okay, but real salty. Probably better to get it without ham. Cheesy garlic bread is good though, and their marinara sauce is spot on. There boneless tenders are really good, definitely the best thing I ordered there.
Bob Ruggio
One of my favorite pizza shops in Oswego, NY. Pretty diversified menu to accommodate everyone in the family whether it’s a quick lunch, dinner or late night grub. Stop in, take-out, or delivery available.
zoey young
Food was cold and the dough was super dry and the pizza had no flavor. The wings were terribly dry. GJP used to be super good not sure what happened.
Rob Oatman
The dining area is spacious and very clean. Conveniently placed televisions set to sports programming were a neat touch. The New York style pie was everything it needed to be: foldable, oily and tasty. Slices of pepperoni were slightly cupped (yet far less so than you might find on a Buffalo style pizza), and that was a good thing. Napkin dispensers are located at each table. This is always a bonus for me. It’s annoying when you are allotted just a few wipes and need to ask for more. The French fries were one step above average. Red Gold ketchup, though?!?!? C’mon guys, how much more does it cost to buy Heinz? Seriously.
Renae Welling
Used to order from here a lot. Had a bad experience once but decided to give it another shot, BIG MISTAKE! Stromboli was flavorless and the garlic donuts (sold as knots but they look like donuts) tastes like burnt plastic. At the price I expected a delicacy but got nothing better than Little Cesar’s quality at five times the price.
Francine Sanford
GJp has always been my go to for pizza and wings. Now it’s my go to for catering. We have ordered for a graduation party and for a family gathering. Food was hot, fresh and delicious!! Highly recommend.
Rosemary Simmons
The absolute worst 27 dollar small pizza I have ever had
… View more