Based on 220 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
6 Elmer St, Madison, NJ 07940
Phone: (973) 295-6996
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–6 PM |
| Monday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christina Ragusa
Some of the best BBQ I had in a while, the flavors were perfect and everything was so juicy! Ngl by the look of it thought it would be dry but the first bite of the turkey (top) was so good, a sweet smokey flavor! Would recommend adding a sauce though! Mac & cheese, beans, corn bread, brisket literally everything was SO good! The owner was really nice too! Would definitely come back!
… more
Michael Friedman
This Colorado-style BBQ joint can boast that it has some of the best meat around. We got the three meat combo—ribs, pulled pork, and brisket. All three are highly recommended. The owner sat down and talked to us for a long time and answered any questions that we had. This is a destination spot for BBQ lovers
… more
Patricia McGowan
Lovely Casual Atmosphere with an upbeat Crew. Uniquely smoked meats, appetizers, and dishes. Complete catering and an outdoor party room with a bar outback. There business is primarily Catering to events big or small.
… more
D. Jaxxson
If you are ever in Madison, New Jersey in the down two area. Please stop by here. This is a funky little joint with BIG flavored BBQ. We had the sampler and the smoked turkey and brisket stood out. Now, the ribs, sausage and pulled porker held its own as well. Oh, they give you a garnishing of pickles that pairs well with meat. To boot they start you off with a healthy dose of hand cut and fried potato chips. Plenty of smoke, flavor and food. Can’t wait to stop in again. Oh, the proprietor and his staff are really down to earth. Made us feel comfortable and that means we will be back. Stop in and get some!
… more
Amira Saleh
Absolutely amazing bbq restaurant. My husband and I stopped by after seeing the rave reviews and it lives up to the hype!! The staff (especially the servers) were absolutely incredible, friendly, accommodating. The brisket was so tender and highly recommend the Mac and cheese. Feel good family restaurant in Madison, NJ!
… more
sahand sb
It was a very friendly place with nice backyard and the food and portions were good! Give them a shot!
… more
Irene Chen
This is a very cozy family owned BBQ, in fact I think this place is actually a house with the BBQ done in the backyard and kids were helping at the restaurant. I really love the cozy atmosphere and the idea of supporting a local business. It truly is a mom and pop joint with the kids helping out. Kudos to our server whose one of the sons for taking care of our table, he was very friendly and attentive. Now as for the food, it’s almost like the BBQ you get at home. I’m not a huge BBQ fan and this place did not win me over. The ribs were tender and it fell off the bones so that was good. The brisket was like any other brisket, the pulled chicken was like shredded chicken, the sausage was nothing special, the pulled pork was okay. Overall not impressed with the food, it lacks flavor and the sauces we were provided with were buttermilk ranch, mustard and BBQ. You would definitely need to add sauce to eat most of the meats especially the chicken, otherwise it’s dry breast meat. I am not a big sauce person, I fully believe in tasting the food before adding any condiments to it but at this place I wished there were more sauces offered so I can at least have some flavor with my meal.
… more
Christine N
I’ve been meaning to leave this review for some time now. We we’ve been to Daddy Matty’s three times now and each time it’s been so delicious. The combo meats platter is a great deal for all you get, and the turkey and sausage are must tries…they are unexpectedly extra flavorful and delicious. The Montreal sandwich is amazing. The stewed beans side is different but ridiculously good, and the coleslaw is fantastic as well. Even the jalapeño popper appetizer is amazing, which is saying something because it’s spicy and I normally hate spicy foods (like medium salsa is too much for me) – I suffer through the heat for the flavor.
… more
Amanda Díaz
This might be the best barbeque I’ve ever had. It was so good! We got brisket and pulled pork sandwiches and the meat was so tender and juicy. The barbeque sauce was awesome too, I think you could describe it as a lighter bbq sauce, rather than super thick and hearty. It was different but super good. Service was great! I highly recommend coming here!
… more
Sheehan Ahmed
The ribs and beef brisket were amazing! The live blues were a delightful, unexpected addition!
… more
… View more