Based on 88 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
Address:
10 Vernon Ave, Hamburg, NJ 07419
Phone: (973) 823-9400
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lex Ramos
I ordered the grilled sirloin steak salad and a personal meat lovers pizza from this local establishment. I request the steak be rare and it was cooked correctly! The salad was fresh & the blue cheese that came with it was delicious. The personal meat lovers pizza wasn’t quite thin and crispy enough as I ordered a thin but it was still great tasting as well, and a decent size for the price. The meat on the pizza was also very tasty. I would come here again!
… more
Derek Porter
Delicious food top to bottom. We order weekly. Have never been upset with any dish from the appetizers to the entrees. Traditional flavors that remind you of Ma’s cooking. Sorrentino dish is outstanding. Go there asap, you won’t regret it!
… more
Christopher Magnus
Lowered review because you still haven’t changed your prices or menus which means you are either skimming the IRS or you haven’t got a single clue what you are doing.
… more
Nathan Foulds
Ordered online and upon going to pick it up, they said the printer wasn’t working right and they never got order but then found it (on a screen???) and it would take 10 minutes. Then told… we’re out of Rissoto. Made new choice and told it would be about 10 more minutes to get everything. 15 minutes in, advised they were making new garlic knots for us. Got home to find two of three dishes had no pasta at all. With that said, my shrimp pasta in pink sauce was awesome. Garlic knots fresh and tasty. Eggplant parm (no pasta) was delicious. Chicken (no pasta) was very good. Friendly and very apologetic young staff. Online ordering and take-out was a total nightmare failure and not recommended but the food we actually got was great. Call order in, don’t do online as there is no real order confirmation guarantee.
… more
Nancy Rivera
The service and quality of food is inconsistant. They forgot to deliver our soda the 1st time we ordered but pizza was great. They got our order correct the 2nd time but pizza was dried out and burnt. We ordered extra cheese the 3rd time and went ourselves to pick it up. They told us 15 to 20 minutes but we had to wait 45 minutes and they forgot the extra cheese. The girl at the counter was rude when we asked about the wait and cheese. We won’t be back there again.
… more
Danielle M
Best pizza and food around Staff is courteous , excellent service there is no food up here that even comes close ! The quality of the pizza and dinners WOW I am never dissatisfied ! , this is not your typical pizzeria !! if you’re new around here you should definitely give them a try , you will not be disappointed ! FYI definitely check out their weekend dinner specials
… more
Dixie Rectid
From perfectly cooked pizza to exquisite, traditional Italian dishes, Gencarelli’s goes above and beyond the average pizzeria. Even with so many options to choose from, placing your order here is a no brainer. With so many places claiming to use ” fresh” ingredients it’s obvious that Gencarelli’s is indeed one of them. Making virtually everything in house, these bold, authentic dishes combined with acceptional service and fair prices make Gencarelli’s a tasty and memorable experience for the whole family. If you haven’t given these guys a shot I strongly suggest you go in, or order delivery and taste the difference!
… more
BARBARASKLAR
We love knowing that every order is going to be delcious… our favorite the tortellini in pnk sauce with prosciutto and peas….. even the side salad is great mix of fresh field greens and THAT in itself is an A+++. Added bonus, the staff and delivery people are always friendly and polite… Thank you so much!
… more
Jennifer Axt
I love this place, usually go once a week. All the staff is very friendly and polite. I never have a problem with any of the food I order, the fried calamari is especially delicious. I would definitely recommend this restaurant
… more
ronna mucklow
Pizza tasted good, however a large pie is the size of dominoes. First time ordering not impressed. I’ll have to stick to Frank’s and pick it up.
… more
… View more