Based on 205 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
Address:
25716 W Loomis Rd, Wind Lake, WI 53185
Phone: (262) 895-3797
Website: http://garys-windlake.edan.io/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Devin Schmitz
Good food. A bit pricey but u get what I pay for.
… more
Debra Spaulding
On a Sunday we were heading elsewhere but when we drove past we did a U turn and stopped in. Been meaning to check it out. IT was late lunch time not crowded at all the atmosphere is very welcoming. Although we sat at the bar for a burger and a beer. The dinning area is a nice size room. We met Gary very friendly and welcoming. Service was excellent. Had a mush and Swiss burger perfect I well order that again. . Plus the salad bar great selection crisp and fresh. Had my favorite beer on tap. We’ll be back. Want to try the Fish fry. Looks like a great place to watch a Packer game. Huge tv behind the bar. We also met bartender Debbie. Very polite and friendly. I recommend a stop in.
… more
Mike “Log house Mike” P
Nice varied menu, spacious dining room, good prices. Beer breaded shrimp yum.
… more
Linda Dall
Haven’t been to Gary’s in maybe a year. We went to hear the band last night and were pleasantly surprised to find prime rib on the menu. I had the queen cut. It came med rare as ordered and was flavorful. A bit too much rosemary for me but still good. Very reasonable at $16.95 salad bar and soup.
… more
James Jegers
Been here a couple of times. The food has been good each time. Last time I tried the prime rib and it was great. Dinners come with potato (your choice of type) and the salad bar. Prices are reasonable. The inside of the place is casual and nicely decorated in sort of a up north grandmas house style.
… more
Maxine Niedzielski
Food and atmosphere was great. Every meal comes with soup or salad where you get it yourself so it’s exactly what you want. We had the ny steak, chicken strips, lasagna, buffalo wings and pretzel bites and they were all amazing. I’d recommend this to ball my friends. All the staff is friendly and helpful with menu choices. Going again tomorrow to try their fish fry!
… more
Kasie Cox
Some of the best food I have had since we moved out this way 6+ years ago! If they have the prime rib sandwich its to die for. My husband said the Wind Lake Burger was one of the best burgers he has had and the tots are really great especially for carry out during the Stay at Home orders.
… more
Burton Robertson
We will give this place a second chance…
… more
Mango D
Excellent food and service. It was a great value as well. My wife and I fed ourselves and our three boys (two are teenagers) for a very affordable amount. The owner Gary is very attentive to his guests coming by our table many times to make sure everything was to our liking. Would highly recommend you give it a try.
… more
Robert Cummings
The prime rib was very very good. Cooked perfectly and seasoned just right. Very good place to go for an affordable good dinner. Staff was very friendly. Well worth the price and was a pleasant drive as well. It really does not get much better than that.
… more
… View more