Based on 55 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
250 Genesee St, Auburn, NY 13021
Phone: (315) 255-3305
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Aaron Forjone
Always a great sheet and best price in town, usually under $25 and if you like a thin crust, this is for you if you want a fat bready one try Mr.pizza
… more
SUSAN GARRIGAN
We have been ordering from Gaetanos for years. We love their pizza! Sauce is yummy!
… more
Mr Dymock
Food is pretty good but that’s when you are able to order it. I’ve called this place 6 times in the last month and the listed hours on google say its open but no one ever answers the phone . The 1 time I did order the guy at the counter was really nice albeit clearly overworked as he seemed to be running the show alone . Higher more staff correct your listed hours and you will be in decent shape .
… more
Andrew Walter
Good pizza if they would ever answer the phone I’ve called 3 times the last week and no one picks up.
… more
Chris OConnor
My Gaetano’s experience was exceptional. The service was excellent —
… more
Jordan Velazquez
As far as service , it was good ! Friendly and got my order together right away. So i gave it three stars cause of the service . Food wise unfortunately not par , steak and cheese sub was dry and didn’t have much flavor . There wasnt enough in the sub it’s self . Skimpy on everything to be honest . I would post a picture if i could . Im from Buffalo NY, I have high expectations for food, and this was not to to even minimum standards on any level . Unfortunately this will be the first and last time i eat there but i wish them the best . There is room for improvement!
… more
Martha Moy
If I could give zero stars I would. First off, the hours on the sign are not right. I’m a delivery driver and Everytime I go there it’s closed. Also, they seem to always be out of something when I actually get an order when they’re open. The biggest issue? The kid that runs the place and has his picture all over the walls! He has no business working with the public!!!! Totally unprofessional and rude!!!
… more
Chef Flip
Had a Delivery…
… more
Margaret Sullivan
After waiting for 1 hour and 40 minutes for our order, the total jumped form 38 when ordered and 52 when delivered. The cold turkey and cheese sandwich I ordered arrived hot as a calzone. When I called the restaurant back they refused to hear that it was a hot sandwich and said no..it was a cold turkey and cheese. We won’t be ordering from here again!
… more
Ann Leonard
I preordered 2 sheet pizzas for my sons bday and had atleast 60 people there. I called them 2 days ago and changed my time to 4pm and they said no problem. My brother went to go pick it up and they were closed! This is not good service!! I will no longer give them my service! Very disappointed
… more
… View more