American breakfasts & sandwiches are menu staples at this neighborhood spot with a relaxed vibe. Based on 376 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
124 Market St, Potsdam, NY 13676
Phone: (315) 268-0109
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Samantha Mizener
Everything tasted great and came out quickly. The staff is all pleasant and makes sure you’re happy with your food. Over all great experience!
… more
Chris S
Nice décor and nice folks. However the food was unremarkable, there was no OJ available for breakfast (we were told the delivery didn’t arrive and apparently nobody wanted to go to the grocery store a half mile away to get some more), the coffee was served to us in plastic (yes plastic) coffee cups, the ‘stuffed French toast’ was undercooked (and should probably be renamed to ‘French toast sandwich’, because it was not stuffed), and upon asking for a replacement of plain French toast we had to wait another 15 minutes, by which time our home fries turned into cold and hard little building blocks. Suggestions include – ceramic coffee cups, never 86’ing the OJ at breakfast time, and having the cook put the replacement orders at the front of the line rather than the back. Best of luck.
… more
Nicholous Rycroft
Would give half a star if the option was available. Don’t bother ordering the steak and eggs for breakfast. I was asked how I’d like it cooked, and I replied “medium rare.” It was basically belt leather. Half of my home fries weren’t cooked and the other half were over cooked. Server didnt have great table manner either. Overall, just unimpressed. On the bright side, I now have a new sole for my shoe!
… more
Alexandra Rogers
Love this awesome local Diner. It is must stop when in Potsdam!! The staff is great & Marcy is the sweetest!
… more
Matt Martin
Always good and their pancakes are like a foot in diameter bigger than a frisbee big as your plate!
… more
E. ARTI Wulandari
The place opens at 7am, so perfect if you’re an early bird. Generous portion, friendly staff, great location.
… more
Randy Pulsifer
Used to be called Caroline’s Diner. New owners but same awesome food. Good prices, HUGE portions
… more
Melanie Grob
Great food and Service. First time here and will definitely be back.
… more
Valerie (Chidori)
Marcy was very friendly and also was funny. I would highly recommend coming here because the food was delicious.
… more
Megan
Both had hot turkey sandwiches with homemade fries, and they were great. Real turkey, tasty gravy, just a really nice meal. It was closer to breakfast time, and the plates going by with those items looked fantastic too! Great service, and it was busy the whole time we were there-always a good sign!
… more
… View more