Straightforward pizzeria chain, also offering casual eats such as chicken wings, subs & salads. Based on 273 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1506 Old Butler Rd, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 656-9222
Website: http://fourstarpizzanewcastle.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eric Peters
I love this place! I use to order weekly when our kids were growing up. Excellent owners and staff. It’s almost like coming home. I don’t see the steak sub. That’s my second choice. Pizza’s my first, extra cheese, pineapple was my son’s favorite. I’m gonna have to try a Deluxe Stromboli sometime.
… more
Kylie Koziol
I been there my whole life because of my aunt Mary and I can stay I am disappointed in how Mike let the place go my pizza had a girls hair cooked in it and when I called they said wasn’t there girls well I been in bed my sons and there father just got the pizza put in on the table and took a bite a BITE OUT OF THE PIZZA WITH THE HAIR COOKED IN IT ewwww
… more
Tami Toxicity
Who’s good but the customer service is absolute trash I was having a connection problem with my phone as I work from the road and the lady on the other end just kept screaming hello after already acknowledging that I was on the other line you should teach your employees customer service used to come here all the time won’t be again
… more
Nicholas Blondsey
Been ordering from this place for years. It’s definitely the best pizza shop in New Castle, PA!
… more
Wes Carroll
I ordered a large pizza an they delivered the wrong pizza . I promptly tried to call them So they could fix my order an they shut the phones off so I couldn’t get my order fixed . An hour later I drive to the store because their phones were still shutoff going right to voice mail an they tell me to bring the pizza back and they would make a new one , when they should have made me my right pizza without all the extra bull , also had me on hold for a solid 15 mins never fixed my order . Had to eat a pizza covered in onions
… more
Trish Fichter
We need more four star pizza shops !! “I hate dominoes !” Its steel n gross.. no taste differenses. Ewwwww…ill starve before ill ever buy !! Dominoes pizza!!!
… more
Jenny Meyer
I have been disrespected twice when calling in a orde. I will never again order from them. Some one else can bur I wont
… more
Aimee Zenobi
We randomly stumbled across this Four Star looking for a place that wasn’t there. We were so excited to find a four star since we no longer had one in our town. The second we walked in we were immediately greeted by the owner, Mike, and he was genuinely welcoming. He accommodated our needs as they are not a sit down pizzeria but he made a small place for us to eat our subs. They were AMAZING. He gave us coupons and also sample slices of pizza. Everything was delicious. He talked to us as if we had known each other for years. Got to know us and was very sincere and great.
… more
Michael “Mike” Berchak
Big salads and good local pizzas will go back next year.
… more
Cody Erlenbach
They charged me 53 cents for 1 single little pack of mayo to put on my 12 inch sub. Lasted for 3 bites.
… more
… View more