Based on 222 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
90 Forest Ave, Glen Cove, NY 11542
Phone: (516) 759-3777
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Teri Messina
Family is warm and friendly coupled with fresh home style dishes. The Tuesday night pasta special is the best bargain in LI and it tastes delicious with fresh salad and baked bread. I have tasted grandma’s pizza all over Glen Cove and LI and their’s wins first prize! Enjoy!
… more
Shaker Nelanuthala
Glen Cove, NY, has several good Italian restaurants, but Forest Avenue Pizza stands out to be really authentic. Why do I say that, everyone who works there is an Italian American and they make food the way they like to eat, awesome place. Last I had, Chicken Marsala and I really sat and savored it. They also offer Tue night specials at a reasonable $$. Closed Mondays. Go and give it a go!
… more
Howard Witz
Just ordered for the first time. Ordered my benchmark meal to test the mettle of a pizza restaurant. Veal Parm.Hero. 10/10 stars. Super delicious. A TON of veal. No tough baseball-mitt pieces. Great sauce, tons of cheese. PIPING HOT on delivery. (Tear-INV up). F&ck@n DELICIOUS!
… more
Issei Kohama
Great place to dine. Good food. Will come again!
… more
Martha Nelson
Who knew?? Best pizza by far. Where V pizza dough is too hard, Forest is too soft. But, the taste, the flavor, more than makes up for it. So cheesy and flavorful. Did I mention the size of the slice. It’s so big, it’s huge. Two people can eat one slice. When you bite into it, you can’t help but say to yourself, they don’t make pizza like this anymore. I remember seeing a coupon in the paper. I can’t recall the details. But, go get it if you see it, this pizza is delicious, the aroma is like, wow, just go get a pie, your friends, family and stomach will thank you for it, so yummy.
… more
Kris Wilhelm
The people that work here are really nice.
… more
Wyatt Cannon
$18 for a regular, a pepperoni and a Buffalo slice is insane. The pizza itself wasn’t really bad. Cheap ingredients and awful products for crazy prices
… more
Valerie Lupo
A great place to grab a slice of delicious pizza! They have so many options it was hard to choose just one! They have a nice outdoor seating area and plenty of seating inside as well!
… more
Sean Burnett
It’s one of my favorite pizzerias. The cauliflower pizza is very good and their eggplant pizza. I don’t go to this pizzeria the most, and I would like to see a ziti slide with ricotta cheese with both marinara and vodka sauces. I remember that they had a slushy machine. I’m not sure if it’s not there anymore, but their cherry slushies were great. When I always walk to get my orders, the employees are nice people and the interior has terrific artworks even though it’s an Italian restaurant, not a museum.
… more
Wayne Cisco
I’ve been coming to Forest pizza for years.. the food is always good! Biggest slices in town! Best pizza in town!!
… more
… View more