Based on 410 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1437 Highland Ave, Melbourne, FL 32935
Phone: (321) 241-4890
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
nick ruber
Went to this pizza place off recommendation from a friend who said their pizza was amazing. Came here on a Saturday night and my friend suggested that we get the pizza to go but we were told it would would have taken 15-20 minutes for a pizza so we decided to sit in. We waited for about 35 minutes before we decided to ask our waitress if the pizza was cooked yet and they had said it was in the oven and it would be out in 5 minutes. 10 minutes later we got the pizza, burnt. The cook was kind enough to offer another pizza on the house on her fault but we figured the wait would have been…more than we waited the first time. Granted, it was a Saturday night and it could be hectic for a chef, I figured the cook would have been capable of making sure a pizza wouldn’t burn to a crisp. Me personally, crust is one of my favorite parts of the pizza but in this case, the picture below will represent what my overall opinion is at FM pizza.
… more
J&A P.
My husband and I absolutely love this place! Everything about FM Pizza makes for a great night out! The food is 5-star delicious! The ambiance & atmosphere is so welcoming and the staff are the best!! I recommend the meatballs for a starter, and the mushroom pizza is phenomenal!!
… more
Vincent Florio
I couldn’t be happier with making the choice to eat here. It’s a cool location but it goes beyond novelty. It makes great use of space, it’s intimate and not crowded but also can accommodate lots of people.
… more
John Espinosa
Enjoyed the meat pot pie. It was very good Cozy atmosphere. One if our orders was mistakenly given to somebody else. We received an apology and had to eat separately. Understand that mistakes can happen but it would have been nice to have been offered even a small consolation.
… more
Susan Boros
Do not take the old bank for granted. Eat in the safe! Being from NJ originally and moved to NC but had to come to FL to find a good pizza again. Talk about selections… Smores pizza of course, Meatball Burata – duh…and everything in between.
… more
Jeffrey Layne (Spectre)
Pizza was great! Crust was a bit thinner than I’m used to but it still tasted good. Only gripe is the wing prices ($14 for 5 small wings). Recommend trying the place, pretty good!
… more
Dezzi Reviews
Location & Vibe is definitely a win for. a pizza night with the family. The food was cooked to order and perfect temperature when it gets to the table. The staff was kind and fun.
… more
Tom Fisher
We travel all the way from Orlando to visit fm pizza.
… more
SHAVON B.
Food is to die for and the customer service was absolutely fantastic. Husband and I arrived during dinner rush without reservation, we were still seated immediately as they had one extra table… though it was for a much larger party than just us. We were seated, and our server knew the menu top to bottom and really gave great recommendations. To be honest, when our first pizza was brought to the table, it was a bit more charred around the edges than I personally care for. (some people like the charred bit so it was understandable as to why it was still served.) Our server overheard me sound slightly disappointed in a conversation with my hubby before we even took our first bite (we were taking pictures and exclaiming over the look and smell of the food). The server immediately interjected that he would have the kitchen start another pie for us and to please dig in and eat what we felt comfortable eating. We felt terrible but happy at the same time. The second pie came out beautifully and everything was so delicious that there is no way you could keep is from coming back! Literally became one of my most favorite places to eat in just one evening..
… more
Jonathan Griffith
Need to get the leak fixed. Margareta pizza mozzarella was authentic, but the crust no so much. A well seasoned brick oven doesn’t need excesdive corn meal to keep the pie from sticking. The pie was good, I would order it again. But it isn’t great enough to bring me back when there are others places I can try to find a great pie.
… more
… View more