Based on 65 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
485 N 2nd E St, Rexburg, ID 83440
Website: https://www.flatrockrexburg.com/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rachael Mickelsen
I came here with my husband and two kids. It’s the cutest restaurant. You walk in and right away you see cheesecakes and ice cream. They have a ton of home decor items displayed all throughout the restaurant, and the layout is super adorable. We went on a Wednesday night at around 6 PM. There were a couple workers there, and they were able to make and bake our food swiftly. We ordered a build-your-own pizza and a bbq chicken pizza. The pizza was fantastic! The flavors really came through, and the crust was crispy. My husband also ordered their root beer float. It was huge! We loved our visit there, and we will be back again soon.
… more
Dallin Maddock
Good pizza! It’s a little confusing and not the quickest, but overall it was good and I would go back. As mentioned in other reviews it is more expensive than Righteous Slice. No reason to not go give it a try!
… more
Heather Cameron
This is the hardest review I’ve ever written because of the two extremes in our experience. We ordered pizza and dessert for takeout. The pizza was amazing! Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. We did the build your own option (all the toppings you want for one price!) The brisket was especially yummy! Delicious and a good value.
… more
Christopher
I honestly think this is the best pizza place in Rexburg. Fast service, quality ingredients, and unlimited toppings! Worth the price especially if you take advantage of the unlimited toppings. They also have a pretty good dessert selection.
… more
Nicholas Ledbetter
We had a great time. The restaurant is a create your own brick oven pizza restaurant. They make delicious pizzas. You don’t pay extra for any toppings including meats from their sister bbq grill restaurant, The Hickory, which is connected to Flat Rock Pizza. They offer great gluten free pizza too, using a delicious Cauliflower crust, which you can’t taste is any different from regular pizza crust. We had a bbq brisket and pulled pork pizza, and a creamy garlic white sauce pizza with bacon and bbq chicken. They were delicious. Prices are about 8-12 dollars per pizza depending on the size you order, gluten free doesn’t cost more. Highly recommend Flat Rock Pizza!
… more
Megan Sonneborn
My husband and I were really excited to try this place because we love MOD in Idaho Falls, but hate the drive. We came in at 12:15 (over an hour after they were supposed to be open) and there was only 1 employee. He hadn’t finished prepping and the nozzles weren’t even on the soda machine yet. Bless his soul because he seemed very new. He was really nice, but it took him a very long time to even get to us (the only ones in the store), let alone to build our pizza. Again, probably because he was new. We waited for probably 10-15 minutes by the time we actually got around to paying and sitting down. It took all of 5 minutes for our pizzas to bake, and they came out burned on the bottom. I’m giving 2 stars because even though it took forever to order and our pizza was burned on the bottom, they still tasted really good!!!! We got the “bacon and mac-n-cheese” and the “smokey hills.” Both were super yummy!!!!
… more
Anna Moore
Service was wonderful, very friendly and attentive. When it comes to the food, it’s eh. If you know the show Brooklyn 99, Boyle’s pizza blast email? Well this pizza really only scored a 5/12. It’s fun that the toppings are like a Chipotle bar. But the pizza just wasn’t great. Not terrible, just okay. You can chose from a list of sauces, cheeses, meats, and other toppings which is fun. But again I cannot stress enough how mediocre this pizza was. Fun environment, cute little gift shop. But the restaurant is connected to The Hickory and shares the kitchen and food. So when I got a side of Mac and cheese it was literally the Mac and cheese from the Hickory which is gross. Food bad, service good!
… more
Beth Johnson
My husband and I were looking forward to trying this place. I have to say, we were disappointed. First off, the customer service was very mediocre. We didn’t know where to order for a minute and not one person greeted us or helped us out. We waited quite a while for our food considering that there was hardly anyone there. The food was also very mediocre. I did like the rosemary crust. My husband on the other hand, hated the texture of the cheese so much, he spit it out. Also, it was extremely overpriced! When we got to the register, I was shocked: $24.00 for two 8 inch pizzas and 2 sodas. We could have gone to Righteous Slice for the same price for full sized delicious pizzas.
… more
Katie Robinson
Straight up so good! If you don’t eat here you might as well just not live. If I had the money I’d buy this place, and then never eat anything but their pizza. HIGHLY ENJOYED.
… more
Kiersten Allen
Wow! There was a dealio deal of the day for a discounted 8″ pizza, so I thought I might as well try this place though it hadn’t piqued my interest before. I am so impressed!! Why have I been going other places for pizza!? Well, that ends today! Unlimited toppings and Super unique specialty pizzas. The crust is amazing and the toppings are super high quality! All this for fairly standard pizza prices! I loved the experience and the pizza tastes incredible!! I’ll definitely be back!
… more
… View more