Five Points Cafe Menu - Sayville, NY

American restaurant with a warm rust-&-brown palette known for burgers made of freshly ground beef. Based on 512 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Five Points Cafe 11782

Address:
1 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782

Phone: (631) 567-5655

Website: https://www.fivepointscafe.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Friday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Sunday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Monday	11:30 AM–9 PM

Drinks
Piot Grigio ~ Ballata, Veneto, Italy Pale straw color, fresh & fruity with a crisp clean finish.
Chardonnay ~ Vintage Oaks, California Light straw color, aromas of tropical fruit and citrus and pear flavors.
Sauvignon Blanc ~ Prophecy, New Zealand Flavors of grapefruit, lychee and Meyer lemon offer crisp, citrus refreshment.
Moscato ~ Pellegrino, Sicily, Italy Sweet & delicate wine with floral bouquet and fresh peach flavors.
Rose ~ Juliette, France Refreshing and crisp rose wine with layers of lively fruit and a bright, smooth finish.
Cabernet Sauvignon ~ Robert Hall, California Black currant, hints of cedar and spice, full bodied with rich and velvety tannins.
Malbec ~ Herencia Trabajo, Mendoza, Argentina Deep garnet red with aromas and flavors of dark cherry and chocolate, elegant soft tannins.
Pinot Noir ~ Townhouse, California Well-balanced displaying opulent fruit with jammy flavors of boysenberries, raspberries & cherries.
Red Sangria
White Sangria
Bud Light, USA	$5.00
Stella Artois, Belgium	$6.00
Bluepoint Brewing Toasted Lager, USA	$6.00
Guinness, Ireland	$6.00
IPA	$8.00
Seasonal	$7.00
Michelob Ultra, USA	$6.00
Heineken / Heineken Light, Holland	$6.00
Corona / Corona Light, Mexico	$6.00
Miller Lite	$6.00
Non-Alcoholic	$6.00
Downtown Mojito/ Strawberry / Coconut Fresh mint and limes muddled with Bacardi rum, simple syrup, club soda	$12.00
Blood Orange Paloma Silver tequila, lime juice, simple syrup, fresh blood orange juice, club soda, tajin rim	$12.00
Cherry Grove Punch Malibu rum, peach schnapps, triple sec, orange juice, pineapple, grenadine, sprite	$11.00
Rose Lemonade Rose wine, lemonade, splash club soda	$12.00
Whiskey Peach Tea Jim Beam, peach schnapps, triple sec, sweet tea	$12.00
Limoncello Spritz Prosecco, Limoncello, Club Soda, Fresh mint	$12.00
Jalapeno Mule Jalapeno infused tequila, lime, ginger beer	$11.00
Downtown Lemonade Stoli Razz, Blue curacao & lemonade	$12.00
Jalapeno & Cucumber Margarita Spicy tequila, muddled cucumbers, lime juice, triple sec, sour, tajin rim	$14.00
Mango Margarita Yave mango tequila, lime, cointreau, sour mix, tajin rim	$14.00
Cucumber-Tini Crops cucumber vodka, St. Germaine, lemonade	$14.00
Coconut-Tini Malibu rum, vanilla vodka, creme de coconut, splash OJ, coconut flakes	$14.00
Blood Orange Tini Felene vodka, Cointreau, Lime juice, Fresh Blood Orange juice	$14.00
Watermelon Cosmo Watermelon vodka, lime juice, triple sec, splash cranberry	$14.00
Blood Orange Margarita	$11.00
Strawberry Margarita	$11.00
Coconut Margarita	$11.00
Classic Margarita	$11.00
Mudslide Kahlua, vanilla vodka, irish cream, vanilla ice cream	$14.00
Chocolate Colada Silver rum, coco lopez, chocolate ice cream	$14.00
Strawberries & Cream Vodka, strawberry puree, irish cream, vanilla ice cream	$14.00
Snickers Caramel Vodka, Chocolate Liquor, chocolate ice cream	$14.00
May Specials
Pulled Pork Nacho Pulled pork, black beans, corn, cheese sauce & pico de gallo served with a side of sour cream.	$15.00
Chicken & Shrimp Fajitas Marinated chicken and shrimp sauteed with peppers & onions served with a side of rice & beans, guacamole & sour cream.	$18.00
Strawberry Spinach Salad Grilled chicken, baby spinach, strawberries, cucumbers & red onions served with honey balsamic dressing on the side.	$15.00
Spicy Shrimp Tacos Crispy shrimp, shredded cabbage, avocado & chipotle aioli.	$15.00
Mexican Burger Our 8oz beef burger topped with pepper jack cheese, guacamole & pico de gallo served with choice of side.	$16.00
June Specials
Ahi Tuna Sliders Grilled Ahi tuna, lettuce, tomato & cucumber drizzled with Cajun aioli	$14.00
Mediterranean Salad Chickpeas, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, feta cheese & red onions over romaine and baby spinach served with a lemon vinaigrette	$14.00
Teriyaki Pork Burger Pork Patty topped with pepper jack cheese, grilled pineapple , lettuce, tomato & red onion , Drizzled with a teriyaki aioli served with choice of side	$16.00
Cajun Shrimp Tacos Cajun grilled shrimp, shredded cabbage & mango salsa served with a side of rice	$16.00
Turkey BLT Fresh turkey with cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato & avocado ranch served on marble rye toast with choice of side	$14.00
July Specials
Coconut Shrimp Coconut battered shrimp served with orange marmalade sauce.	$12.00
Watermelon & Feta Salad Romaine lettuce, feta cheese, cucumbers, red onions & watermelon drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$13.00
Blackened Mahi Tacos (2) Blackened Mahi, shredded cabbage, mango salsa drizzled with chipotle aioli with french fries.	$16.00
Chicken Teriyaki Kebabs Teriyaki glazed chicken, peppers & onions, served over rice.	$16.00
BBQ Pork Wrap Shredded pulled pork, rice, black beans, corn & shredded cheddar cheese served with french fries.	$16.00
August Specials
Fried Zucchini Crispy zucchini sticks served with a side of marinara sauce	$12.00
Crabby Salad Romaine lettuce, sliced mango, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers & red onion topped with our homemade crabcake served with a lemon oil vinaigrette dressing on the side	$18.00
Jerk Chicken Quesadilla Marinated jerk chicken, pepper jack cheese, & mango salsa pressed together on a flour tortilla served with choice of side	$16.00
Caprese Burger Our 8 oz beef burger topped with mozzarella cheese, basil, sliced tomato & balsamic glaze served with choice of side	$13.00
Baja Fish Tacos (3) Crispy cod, avocado, coleslaw and Baja sauce	$18.00
September Specials
Fried Pickles Served with chipotle aioli	$11.00
Cali Veggie Bowl Our veggie burger over mixed greens, black beans, pico de gallo, rice, shredded cheddar & roasted sweet potatoes served with avocado ranch dressing on the side	$16.00
Buffalo Chicken Flatbread Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, shredded mozzarella & scallions served on crispy flatbread with a side of blue cheese dressing	$14.00
Shrimp Cucumber Wrap Grilled shrimp, feta, cherry tomatoes, baby spinach & roasted red peppers wrapped in a cucumber tortilla wrap served with choice of side	$17.00
Chicken Parm Ala Vodka Crispy chicken cutlet over penne pasta tossed in ala vodka sauce & topped with a crown of fried mozzarella	$18.00
Football Specials
Buffalo Mac N Cheese Crispy buffalo chicken, mac & cheese, breadcrumb	$11.00
Chili Tacos (3) Our homemade chili, shredded cheddar & sour cream	$9.00
Loaded Fries Crispy chicken, cherry peppers, mozzarella cheese, chipotle aioli	$12.00
Pesto Chicken Flatbread Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes, pesto aioli	$12.00
Pulled Pork Nachos Pulled pork, cheese sauce, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream	$11.00
5 Points Sample 3 potato skins, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 chicken fingers, 2 pulled pork sliders	$18.00
Reuben Skins 3 potato skins with Corned beef, swiss cheese, kraut, Russian dressing	$11.00
$0.75 Wings Bone-In Choice of Buffalo, BBQ, Cajun Dry Rub – Minimum of 5 wings
$12 Bud Light Pitchers
$2 Off Drafts & Bottles
November Specials
Mexican Street Corn Shrimp Sweet corn battered shrimp, guacamole, pickled red onions, drizzled with Cajun aioli	$14.00
Pork Belly Sliders – (2) Served on pretzel bun sliders with crispy onions, cheddar cheese, & chipotle aioli served with sweet potato tots	$15.00
Grilled Apple Salad Mixed greens topped with grilled chicken ,pecans, blue cheese crumbles & grilled apples served wtih honey balsamic dressing on the side	$15.00
Bacon & Brie Burger Our beef burger topped with crisp bacon, caramelized onions & brie cheese served with choice of side	$16.00
Roasted Brussel Sprout Flatbread Goat cheese, shaved brussel sprouts, crispy bacon & pickled red onions drizzled with balsamic glaze	$15.00
December Specials
Baked Clams (4) Stuffed chopped clams	$14.00
Pear & Pomegranate Flatbread Grilled pears, blue cheese crumbles, arugula and pomegranates drizzled with balsamic glaze	$15.00
Spicy Pastrami Hot pastrami on toasted marble rye, pepper jack cheese and spicy coleslaw, served with french fries	$16.00
Burger Bowl Choice of chicken or beef burger over romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar, rice, cherry tomatoes, red onions and pickles, served with a side of thousand island dressing	$16.00
Meatloaf Our homemade meatloaf with mashed potatoes and carrots, served with a side of gravy	$18.00
January Specials
Buffalo Cauliflower Breaded cauliflower, buffalo sauce, blue cheese crumbles, scallions	$9.00
Burrata Ravioli Burrata cheese raviolis in a light tomato sauce topped with parmesan cheese	$18.00
Chopped Chickpea Salad Mixed greens & romaine lettuce, cucumbers, chickpeas, red onions, pecans, feta cheese & avocado served with lemon oil vinaigrette dressing	$16.00
Pulled Pork Quesadillas BBQ pulled pork, cheddar cheese, mango salsa & scallions, side of sour cream, French fries	$17.00
Crispy Spinach & Artichoke Sandwich Crispy chicken, roasted red peppers, creamy spinach & artichoke dip on ciabatta, choice of side	$16.00
February Specials
Burrata Flatbread Crispy flatbread topped with arugula, burrata cheese and cherry tomatoes drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$15.00
Braised Short Ribs Boneless short ribs over mashed potatoes topped with crispy onions.	$20.00
Cuban Wrap Roasted pork, grilled ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard in a tortilla wrap served with French fries.	$16.00
Spinach & Mushroom Quesadilla Baby spinach & sauteed mushrooms, pepper jack cheese pressed in a warm tortilla served with French fries.	$15.00
Chocolate Covered Strawberries 4 per order.	$9.00
Food
Spinach & Artichoke Dip	$10.50
Salsa & Chips	$7.50
Sliders	$11.50
Guacamole & Chips	$10.50
Mozzarella Sticks	$8.50
Buffalo Wings Buffalo, BBQ or Cajun Dry Rub	$12.50
Boneless Wings Buffalo, BBQ or Cajun Dry Rub	$12.50
Chili Loaded Nachos	$13.50
Pulled Pork Sliders	$11.50
Giant Pretzel & Cheese Sauce	$11.50
Mexican Street Corn Shrimp Street corn battered shrimp, guacamole, cajun aioli, pico de gallo	$15.00
Fried Pickles Served w/ chipotle aioli	$9.95
Fresh Homemade Soups	$6.95
French Onion	$8.50
Chili	$9.95
Avocado Tomato Salad Avocados, tomatoes and red onions, drizzled with fresh lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil and crushed black pepper over field greens with choice of dressing.	$13.95
Chipotle BBQ Chicken Grilled marinated chicken, mixed greens, tomato, avocado, tortilla strips and chipotle ranch dressing, drizzled with a smokey BBQ sauce.	$15.95
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Hearts of romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons and classic caesar dressing.	$14.95
Topless Burger Just the burger on a bed of greens with tomatoes, cucumbers and carrots with choice of dressing.	$15.95
Chicken Cobb Romaine, grilled chicken, avocado, cherry tomatoes, bacon, blue cheese, hard boiled eggs and choice of dressing.	$16.50
Grilled Fresh Ahi Tuna Tuna coated with sesame seeds, seared rare with house pickled ginger, aged soy and fresh wasabi on a bed of greens with tomatoes, cucumbers and carrots with choice of dressing.	$17.95
Grilled Shrimp Salad Marinated grilled shrimp served over a bed of field greens with cucumbers, red peppers, red onions, goat cheese and roasted tomatoes served with balsamic dressing.	$17.75
Southwest Salad Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, avocdao, tomatoes, black beans, red peppers, corn, shredded cheese, chipotle dressing in a tortilla bowl.	$15.95
Downtown Chicken Salad Grilled chicken over a bed of field greens with bacon, red onions, cranberries, pecans, feta cheese, roasted tomatoes served with balsamic dressing.	$15.95
Classic Burger 8oz of our fresh 100% all American beef patty.	$15.50
American Cheese Burger Served with classic American cheese.	$16.50
Classic Patty Melt Served with Swiss cheese, sauteed onions on marble rye.	$16.50
Bacon Cheese Burger Classic American cheese and applewood smoked bacon.	$16.50
Downtown Burger Cheddar, mozzarella and American cheese, bacon, onion straws smothered in our Secret Five Star sauce.	$17.50
Buffalo Style Beef Burger Red hot sauce and blue cheese	$16.50
Steakhouse Burger Blue cheese, onion straws and horseradish sauce.	$17.25
Cali Burger Cheddar, avocado and chipotle ranch.	$16.25
Crabby Patty Homemade grilled jumbo lump crab cake, pepper jack cheese served with cool wasabi cucumber sauce.	$16.75
Chicken Burger Fresh ground chicken blended with tomato and parmesan cheese topped with mozzarella.	$15.75
Turkey Burger Turkey burger, pepper jack cheese, guacamole and chipotle ranch.	$15.75
Veggie Burger Sweet potato and spinach blended with fresh herbs and spices.	$14.75
Burger Of The Day	$15.75
Build Your Own Burger	$15.50
Classic Reuben Shaved Carnegie Deli corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on marble rye.	$14.95
Cajun Chicken Sandwich Cajun marinated chicken breast with lettuce, tomato and Cajun aioli on a multigrain roll.	$14.95
Grilled Cheese An old classic serve don your choice of bread.	$9.95
Classic Chicken Sandwich Grilled chicken sandwich on multigrain roll, choice of mayo, BBQ or five star sauce.	$14.95
Classic BLT Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on marble rye.	$13.50
Parmesan Crusted Chicken Sandwich Parmesan panko crusted chicken breast, roasted red peppers and pesto mayo on a multigrain roll.	$15.50
Steak Sandwich Steak, mozzarella cheese, sauteed onions and horseradish dressing on a garlic toasted sub roll.	$18.75
Pulled Pork Sandwich Slow roasted pulled pork, cheddar cheese, drizzled with BBQ sauce, on a garlic toasted sub roll.	$15.95
Avocado Chicken Caprese Sandwich Grilled chicken with fresh mozzarella and sliced tomato with avocado and a balsamic glaze on a ciabatta bun served with your choice of side.	$15.50
Downtown Chicken Melt Crispy chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon with avocado ranch on ciabatta.	$14.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.	$14.75
Cali Chicken Wrap Crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, cheddar cheese, avocado, bacon and chipotle dressing.	$15.25
Cajun Chicken BLT Wrap Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, shredded cheese and chipotle aioli.	$15.25
Buffalo Chicken Wrap Crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, blue cheese crumbles , tomatoes and buffalo sauce.	$15.25
Veggie Wrap Crispy eggplant, spinach, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, roasted tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and balsamic glaze.	$14.95
Chicken Burrito Wrap Grilled chicken wrapped in a warm flour tortilla with rice, beans, cheddar cheese and house made pico de gallo.	$15.50
Shrimp Burrito Cajun shrimp wrapped in a warm flour tortilla with rice, beans, cheddar cheese, Cajun aioli and house-made pico de gallo.	$18.50
Fish & Chips Icelandic crisp ale filet of cod with French fries and tartar sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Tenders Chicken tenders and fries.	$14.50
Chicken Quesadilla Grilled chicken, pico de gallo, shredded cheese in a crispy flour tortilla, served with a side of sour cream and French fries.	$14.50
Ahi Tuna Tacos Rare tuna coated with sesame sees, shredded cabbage and mango salsa drizzled with cucumber wasabi dressing.	$17.95
Cajun Chicken Tacos Cajun chicken with lettuce, tomato, shredded cheddar, pico de gallo and aioli.	$15.95
Mac And Cheese Classic Homemade creamy shells and cheddar topped with buttery baked bread crumbs.	$14.50
Tuna Poke Bowl Fresh ahi tuna over rice, mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, scallions, avocado and chipotle aioli drizzle.	$18.50
Five Points Bowl Crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, avocado, corn, black beans, tomatoes, rice and a side of avocado ranch.	$16.50
BBQ Chix Flatbread Crispy chicken, BBQ sauce, Mozzarella cheese, scallions, ranch	$15.00
Downtown Flatbread Grilled chicken, arugula,goat cheese, pecans, cranberries, balsamic glaze	$15.00
Shrimp Pesto Flatbread Grilled shrimp, mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes, baby spinach, pesto aioli	$17.00
Idaho French Fries	$7.25
Sweet Potato Fries	$8.25
Beer Battered Onion Rings	$8.25
Waffle Fries	$8.25
Coleslaw	$6.25
Fresh Green Salad	$6.25
Mac And Cheese	$8.25
Chicken Fingers And Fries	$7.75
Kids Mac And Cheese	$7.75
Sliders And Fries	$7.75
Grilled Cheese And Fries	$7.75
Hot Dog And Fries	$7.75
Cheese Quesadilla And Fries	$7.75
Iced Tea	$2.75
Unsweetened Iced Tea	$2.75
Lemonade	$2.75
Coke	$2.75
Diet Coke	$2.75
Sprite	$2.75
Ginger Ale	$2.75
Root Beer Bottle	$3.50
Bottled Water	$2.50
Coffee	$2.50
Tea	$2.50
Milk	$2.50
Chocolate Milk	$2.50
Vanilla Milkshake	$7.50
Strawberry Milkshake	$7.50
Chocolate Milkshake	$7.50
Cookies And Cream Milkshake	$7.50
Root Beer Float	$6.50
Fudge Brownie Sundae Warm brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce and whipped cream.	$5.95
Deep Fried Donuts Deep fried donut topped with vanilla ice cream, chocolate & caramel drizzle.	$6.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ashley O’Connor

My husband and I eat here pretty regularly, and the food and service are always top-notch. We’ve tried many of their menu items, some of our favorites being the southwest salad, chipotle bbq chicken salad, the reuben, and the blt. Their monthly specials are always delicious as well! We love eating on their outdoor patio that is dog-friendly. The servers are always so sweet to our dog and bring her a water bowl every time. They also have live music on certain days. Great, casual restaurant to hang out and get a consistently good meal!

Jennifer Pierce

My family has eaten here a few times. The burgers are fine but DO NOT get the lobster roll!!!! It was terrible. Go to claws and pay less for top quality. This was fishy leftover pieces full of mayo. So much mayo it was uneatable. I didn’t want to complain in front of people we brought out but after leaving my husband did not feel well so if you do not want to be sick do not order this menu item this summer or you will be sorry like us

Glenn

Nice local, live music, good for a Friday (end of week) dinner. Cozy and friendly, staff are all nice. Bartender serves drinks in any old clean glass, weather a beer or not….so probably should order a beer! Recommend and will be back.

Blanca

1st time I’ve eaten there and it was really good! There was a 30 minute wait at around 6:45 on a Saturday night so we sat at the bar. Selina, the bartender was attentive. Ordered the Cajun chicken sandwich with cheddar and a salad. The sandwich was very tasty and the sauce had a nice “kick.” The kitchen staff kept just kept pumping out orders (to go & dine-in). There was live music too.

Kevin Mat

Ended up here on a whim, and it was so great. The food, the drinks, the atmosphere, the music… everything was seriously tremendous!

Arleen Farina

Great place especially in the summer Outdoor seating is so nice They have live music some evenings Casual food and friendly staff

Lisa Biancospino

It I think this is about the fourth time I’ve been here and it’s always wonderful the food is excellent in fresh the service is great and just a nice place to go in get a burger get a sandwich they have a nice variety on the menu

Peter Wilkeyson

Stopped in for a beer and burger.. Awesome atmosphere for a midweek jaunt.. Live music .. Great Food.. and a small great selection of tap beers.. Westhampton Beach Irish Eyes Stout.. was fantastic too..

James Wood

Great food and drinks. Beautiful private outdoor seating. Great service. Would definitely recommend!

Kamil S

We got seated promptly. Place has nice outdoor sitting area which was main reason we picked it. Some live music which ended 15 mins after we sat down. Server was pleasant although failed to check on us. Mosquitoes were biting us, they did have citronella candles but have not offered to turn them oil on for us. Food was nothing special. I had the cali and burger that cost 15 bucks. Had better burgers even chillis has better burgers. Kids food came was brought after we were done with our food. Why they would not serve us all at the same time? I had to feed my kid from my plate. It was only chicken tenders ans fries.

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Five Points Cafe Menu – Sayville, NY

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions