Based on 90 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
Address:
7 Newman St, Winter Harbor, ME 04693
Phone: (207) 963-5585
Website: http://www.fishermansgalleymaine.com/
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Theresa Lambertucci
Very fresh lobster rolls and fish sandwiches, the best in Maine. We actually had to get extra to take home. Beautiful views, family owned and beautiful area. I would definitely go back again. Thank you for an awesome lunch.
… more
Jim and Debbie Mangiapane
The restaurant is not open, but they have created an outdoor patio that you can order from and grab a table with a great view of the ocean. The hot dogs are large and very tasty. The haddock sandwich was just right, and the blueberry pie was one of the best we have ever had. Bought a whole one to take home! Staff is very friendly and it’s a great place to visit on a beautiful day.
… more
David Weiss
A guy wearing a lobster hat should have been a warning. No prices on menu. One sausage, one haddock sandwich, fries, pickle, beer, and lemonade=$45.00. Food was okay. No service, sit outside next to a busy road, and pick up your food. There are better options.
… more
Richard Passantino
A while back Rosemarie and I went to Fisherman’s Inn for dinner. I ordered the fried haddock and Rosemarie ordered the lobster mac and cheese. As we started our first bite we both knew something was completely wrong with both orders. The haddock was barley warm and greasy. The lobster and mac was loaded with hot sauce. We immediately brought this to the attention of the owner. He was polite and explained that the cook was leaving in less than a week and he believed he was a short timer and possibly did this intentionally. The owner never offered us a new meal. If I was the owner I would have said to my customers, “I would like you to order a new meal, anything you like and it will be on me.” And, you are welcome to desert and coffee.” But this was never mentioned. The owner did refund both meals and we left discouraged. A terrible experience. It is hard to believe the owner did not offer a resolution to this situation, however, it was for the best.
… more
Ben McMillan
Matt and Nui are the owners of this fine establishment. They are super warm and friendly and treat you like family. Great food,make sure to try there lobster roll! #themcmillanexpress
… more
Tom Lucht
Sad and dirty. Overpriced of the atmosphere. Food was just ok. Do not waste your time.
… more
Rose McGraw
First visit was nice. Second visit was total polar opposite. I would not recommend this place due to not caring if they insult the very “tourists” that want to spend their money for food. When asked for recommendations for another place to eat, I kept hearing Bar Harbor..over an hour away. Not a good experience for this tourist
… more
Cate Cichon
Me and my mom went and had the best time! Best lobster rolls, lemonade, and cole-slaw of our lives by far! The nicest people too, one of which rocked a very cool lobster hat! Please go if you can, you won’t regret it!
… more
Adam Gold
This was our favorite cold lobster roll in town. Served by a very cute crew, all outdoor, everyone on the staff was wearing a mask except the lobster roll guy. Regardless he was charming and made a great roll with lots of knuckle meat. They serve it with a house-made lemon mayo squirted on top like ketchup on a hot dog, which was great actually. Just a great pile of meat and a nice tangy mayo, we requested “lite” mayo and i think i’d even go for more.
… more
Journey with the Jakes
Not a bad spot to grab some grub. A little pricey for the portions you get. Waitress was good and the ice cream was good. It’s a different type of feel when you walk in. You have to order your food and then go sit down. Kind of like a fast food joint but not the fast food fare.
… more
… View more