First Prize Mike’s Menu – Schenectady, NY

Type : Hot dog restaurant

Location : Schenectady, NY

Based on 805 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

First Prize Mike's 12305

Address:
1135 Erie Blvd, Schenectady, NY 12305

Phone: (518) 382-9213

Website: https://mikesfirstprize.com/

Hours

Tuesday 6 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 6 AM–10 PM
Thursday 6 AM–10 PM
Friday 6 AM–10 PM
Saturday 6 AM–10 PM
Sunday 6 AM–8 PM
Monday 6 AM–10 PM

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

shawn quackenbush
Tried a hot dog all the way. Meat sauce catsup mustard onions. Below average. Three dollars and thirty four cents. That’s all I’m saying.

… more

Justin Grant
Walked in tonight and was told only dogs and burgers recived pretty much a bun with some what of hamburger meat on it, listed to phone ring the whole time i was there while the 2 behind counter saying whoever calling are idiots that they were just gunna let it keep ringing, last time comeing here because I remember comeing as kid and still stopped in sorry but place has gone down hill

… more

Lynn B
Interior Needs serious updating , that being said, the food is always good, and cooked how you like it, the staff are always friendly. I enjoy the grilled chicken sandwich and onion rings. Other than it really needs updating, it’s great place to eat

… more

Caitlin M
We’ve been eating here for over 30 years, this is the BEST hot dog place I’m Schenectady.

… more

Joseph Stacey
Authentic local experience you can’t find elsewhere. Counter or table seating. Takeout available. Prices are very reasonable and excellent milkshakes. The fries are delicious with skin on. Don’t forget a hotdog! Oh, and they do breakfast and everything is made fresh right in front of you.

… more

Karl Babij
Given that it was Saturday morning, Mike’s was packed. The diner is tiny. It seemed like the whole town was there for breakfast. It was a little hard to get the attention of the servers but when you did everything worked out. I ordered some hot dogs and fries which were great. The only advice I would give is not to come during rush hour.

… more

Stephen Tatasciore
It’s a Mom and Pop shop which is awesome! Cash only! They serve a pretty good hot dog, not the best I’ve had but certainly not the worst. It was on the spicy side which I enjoyed. I would have given them 4 stars but the hot dogs are over priced at $2.40 each, that’s way too much for a simple hot dog with everything as seen in the photo.

… more

Terrance Ray Trybus
This place looks like it could be the star of Guy Fieri’s “Diners, Drive-Ins & Doves”, so of course the food will be good. Made on a grill right in front of you. Quick friendly service, great food. Has to be, they been open for over 70 years.

… more

Eric Anker
Classic hot dog stand. You must try these hand cut fries! Staff is polite and accommodating, easy parking. A gem in Schenectady for a quick bite.

… more

Amy Sonder
Simple, delicious food. You won’t find any fuss or pretense here, just reliably great food and the nicest staff. Come down and see why they’ve been around for over 50 years!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions