Based on 111 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
Address:
593 Main St, Dennis, MA 02638
Phone: (508) 258-5001
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
U Shah
Considering annual visits to Cape Cod and enough fried clams/lobster rolls, akin to hating turkey after Thanksgiving, Firestarter was a fantastic surprise. The wood fired pizza with excellent sauce and fresh ingredients hit the spot. The pizza was perfectly cooked in a Neapolitan style and the service was cordially friendly. Get some fanatic Cape Cod pizza.
Natalie Kais
This was literally one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. And I used to work at one of the top pizza restaurants in NYC!! Can’t remember the name but it had pepperoni and banana peppers. I got it on vacation about 2 weeks ago. I haven’t stopped thinking about it since. Absolutely outstanding
Enola Andoni
I would give this place no stars. I drove half an hour and waited 1 hour and 30 mins to get the pizzas done and I received three burned pizzas. The lady I spoke on the phone was so rude she just hung up on me. She was claiming that these is the way the pizzas are made. Such a waste of money and time.
Samantha Parsloe
Pizza is thin but still doughy. Toppings are fresh and high quality. Hole in the wall anyone would be happy to stumble across. 10/10 would recommend.
Carrie Allsopp
Excited that I found this little spot for my pizza craving! Hit the spot, right on. Was cooked to perfection, crunchy and satisfying chewiness to the dough, and the smell that filled my car – I almost couldn’t wait to have a slice until I got home. Will surely be coming back to have more!
Jessica Albano
Delicious! Plan your day and be sure to order ahead – it’s worth it! If you love wood fired pizza this is the place for you. We got 2 pizzas for 4 people. 1-2 people per pizza is spot on. Thanks so much! We’ll be back.
Richard Chwastiak
Feel honored to have grown w/ Firestarter Pizza from their opening till now. Hands down, best pizza on the Cape as well as a contender for best in the Northeast. Margot and her crew are top notch and our area is extremely lucky to have this business as part of the community.
michael sullivan
If Firestarter Pizza was near our home, it would be our go to pizza place. Instead, we’ll have to wait for our trips up to the Cape.
Jessica Johnson
I highly recommend Firestarter Pizza for any pizza lover. The eat-in or takeout options are endless, delicious and delightful. The atmosphere is warm and eclectic. It invites diners to be social, or to just have a nice quiet meal. The service is great too! Orders are made at the counter, where the beautiful pizza oven can be seen, and the food is brought to you at your table. The staff and owners are very nice and have done everything right here. This place is definitely a must try!
Connor Hennessy
I get this pizza with my girlfriend basically every Friday night over the Summer. It is without a doubt some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m from CT, spent my youth in NYC, and now live in Boston and have tried pizza allover. This pizza ranks in my top three. The buffalo chicken is my girlfriends favorite, the JIM is hearty and full of ingredients, the basic white is superb, but the basic red or plain cheese is out-of-this-world. I think they use some kind of garlic infused oil that gives it this amazing flavor and the tomato sauce tastes fresh, with the perfect amount of cheese. But surprisingly enough the crust is what does it….its incredible. It’s what truly puts the pizza over the edge as top tier. We typically order at least 2 pizzas because we each end up eating an entire pie that night…it’s that addicting. Some may complain about the ordering and pick-up time windows but I just don’t think they understand that this is highly-coveted pizza and you just have to plan ahead. I highly recommend.
… more
… View more