Based on 105 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
92 Public Sq, Andover, OH 44003
Phone: (440) 293-6148
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Ed E
Had pizza here for the first time. We really enjoyed it. It was a pepperoni pizza. Will be going back.
… more
Aric Bechtel
The best pizza in town…real provolone cheese..family run forever…only open Thursday through Sunday at 4 pm
… more
Brian Huntley
Very tasty pizza done right. I had pepperoni rolls, cheese and pepperoni pizzas and all three were delicious, just the way I like them.
… more
John Johnson
What can y’all say
… more
Jamie D’Amico
Me and my husband have tried to order pizza from here at least 15 times over the past 4 or 5 month and every time we call the phone just rings and rings. Then if you go there to just order it in person there is no one there and every few days when I drive by it is locked up with all the lights out inside it really looks closed for business. We heard from several people that this pizza shop was the best around and really wanted to try it out, we are definitely disappointed!!
… more
leilas playlist
Tonight, my husband and I enjoyed a delicious pizza and chef’s salad from this place. It was the best pizza we have eaten in this area. We spend our summers out here. I loved the “mom & pop ” feel when I walked in. The Mr. & Mrs. were so cute and funny. I don’t know why I never teies them before. Fiore & Tony’s you have just gained a new customer!
… more
Tammy Mills
Absolutely the best pizza in Andover. Mouth watering pizza is just what we needed while camping. Try it, you won’t be disappointed
… more
usn az1aw
Bland pizza, threw it out after forcing down 1 slice, and each person was hungry too !! Not sure how that’s possible. Got a pepperoni, sausage & mushroom. Barely any red sauce. Even the sausage was undetectable. Crust was like dry cardboard with no flavor. You could not detect salt, yeast, or olive oil. Not even chewy, crisp. I’ve been all over and to Italy/Sicily…this is NOT good pizza at all, barely edible and not worth the price. Go to Covered Bridge pizza around the corner if you want atleast a decent pie or other options. We’ve had better frozen pizzas out of a box, or at gas stations, or even Dominos. Not trying to be mean, but I really don’t know how the majority of reviews can say authentic or best pizza around. Also got a large chef’s salad with Italian dressing to share. If bagged iceberg lettuce with some torn pieces of ham and some pepperoni slices and a few grape tomatoes is a chef salad, the preparers needs to Google a couple recipes. No hardboiled egg, no turkey, no onions, no croutons, etc. The dressing tasted synthetic, like Kraft. Can’t they do homemade ? If your business is only pizza, atleast make it amazingly fresh and taste like you care about what you’re making and offering.
… more
Debra Getty
Absolutely hands down the best pizza around! Very reasonable and the staff were friendly and I will order from there anytime! I also had a chef salad that was fresh and tons of veggies!
… more
Don Betz
I was up from Pittsburgh visiting a friend and stopped to get a pizza from Fiore &Tony’s. What a pleasant surprise! Some of the best I’ve ever had. Fresh ingredients, great crust, great sauce! Definitely going to get it again! Don Betz Pittsburgh
… more
… View more