Based on 938 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
310 Milwaukee St, Johnson Creek, WI 53038
Phone: (920) 699-8989
Website: https://fiestagaribaldijc.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
CloverChloe
The food would have been amazing, except when I ordered a milk I got unpasteurized milk, which looked and tasted weird, as if it were rotten. And, I’m pretty sure it’s illegal to serve in a restaurant. And, when I told the kitchen staff, they said they had no other milk and that was all they had. I asked for a water instead. The other food was amazing, and I’ve been there several times before, loving it. My personal favorite is enchiladas! Forgive my complaint, the food is usually amazing.
Cassandra McDaniels
Very good food. Service was amazing!
Daniel Gross
Stopped after an afternoon at the mall down the street. We were looking for something else, but decided to stop here when we saw it. Food was great – appreciated they had bottled Apple Soda, a Mexican staple. Nicely decorated and good food, our waiter was friendly and attentive. He didn’t speak much English, but that wasn’t a problem. Food can be prepared American or Mexican style. Will visit again when we are in the neighborhood.
Mary Hahn
The artistic painted murals on the walls are beautiful and interesting to look at. The margaritas were huge and tasted great! And the food was totally awesome!! Not your typical Mexican-American food. The service was excellent too. Jose was a superb waiter! He heard it was my birthday and brought out a slice of delicious cake with a candle, and he let us take his picture. A wonderful experience at this restaurant.
Al B
The staff here are very kind!! However, I ordered chicken enchiladas and the chicken tasted sweet. We thought it was a one time issues and went back again. The second time, the chicken tacos I got also had “sweet” chicken. Not sure if that’s just how they season their food but it was really off putting. Some of their prices are also pretty unreasonable. Food wasn’t very good.
Kelsey
The service was honestly awful and I was slightly surprised based off other reviews. Our server was extremely rude and rarely spoke, making ordering anything very difficult. He also never once checked on us while dining and we waited on the bill longer than anticipated due to this. The food itself was great but unfortunately over priced. I’d possibly give it another chance for service but I would unfortunately not recommend based on this visit.
Neil Hinterberg
Very good taco salad which is one of my favorites in Mexican restaurants. There’s a big variety between restaurants for what goes into the salad and Fiesta Garibaldi had a great mix and a good amount of guacamole on top which some places leave out entirely. Very good chips and salsa were included, Overall a very good dinner!
FREEDOM
Come visit us at Fiesta Garibaldi in Johnson Creek! Conveniently located just beyond the western Milwaukee suburbs, or an easy ride from Madison!
Heather Rathjen
My mom and I came here after having a successful shopping trip at the outlet mall! Unfortunately like MANY businesses right now they are understaffed, but I must say they handled themselves fabulously! We waited maybe a little longer but nothing terrible. Our waitress was super kind, and gave great suggestions on food because I don’t typically eat meat. Which off first appearance their menu isn’t vegetarian/vegan friendly, but I strongly recommend fajita veggie tacos with avocados and cilantro (not on menu but they will easily accommodate)! My mom got the shrimp quesadilla and she was super happy with it. We will be going back!
Gabriela Betthauser
First time there. My husband ordered pollo burrito dinner. He got beef instead. I ordered ceviche tostadas and they were ok. I don’t think we are going back
… View more