Casual Italian restaurant offering homemade, thin-crust pies plus subs & pasta dishes since 1957. Based on 602 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 458-4171
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: alohaorderonline.com
Reviews
MistahZ
I’ve seen Fayes advertised as one of the better pizza places around and while it isn’t the best I’d say it’s good overall! The building is nice inside and out, spacious and clean albeit with a somewhat AWKWARD parking lot to navigate. Service was good and patient, no problem there. The food was good, from the mozzarella sticks to the mini tacos and the pizza, it wasn’t the best I’ve had but it was still tasty. My ONLY complaint is they switched up my pizza as it was a normal one and not a deep dish but it was alright in the end! Try Fayes out but if you’re getting a takeout pizza, check it first to be safe!
Crystal Sie
We got 2 medium specialty pizzas. Someone needs to take the cornmeal shaker away from the cook. Way too much on bottom of pizza turned it disgusting. It was our first and last time ordering from there. Appetizer platter was good.
pat kenworthy
Tried to order there I heard it was great pizza.
Brian Paige
Great place to get a pizza. Prices are reasonable and the pizza is good. The searing area is a bit small so won’t accommodate large gatherings. They also sell their pizzas frozen for a great price to take home to bake.
Brian Ross
I’ve never dined in there, but I manage to order from here at least once a week. Faye’s has never failed me. Top of the line food and service. Thank you and please keep up the good work.
Douglas Davis
Well, Googled Pizza, went to little ol Faye’s while passing through. Never have I had more cheese on a pizza. Deep dish supreme minus anchovies with xtra cheese. Pizza pie came out!!! I’m delightfully stuffed…. 2 guys couldn’t finish this 12 inch medium. Thick? YES! Tasty? Double yes!!
Nicole Knudson
Used to be my one of my favorite places to get pizza but the last year or so, more times than not my pizzas are over cooked. Thinking I’m going to start trying other places because all 3 pizzas last night were overcooked so the cheese was brown and not even melty.
Constance arrivi
Worst place ever tried to order from they tried to charge me twice what they advertised and then got hung up on by there manager Peter cause he told me if I wasn’t going to pay what he said I wasn’t getting my food. And If I didn’t like it to bad call when the owner is there in the morning. Horrible business.
Beverly Voechting
Always our go to pizza place in Sheboygan! Love their crispy thin crust! Pizza is really good!
Courtney Handeland
Amazing thin crust pizza! So flavorful! The Cheeseburger pizza was fantastic and the garlic cheese bread was also robust in flavor.
… View more