Fatman’s Pizza is the place to go when you want a handcrafted pizza on-the-go that doesn’t sacrifice on quality or delicious taste! We’ve been serving up mouthwatering selections since the 1970s, but we’ve recently started our next journey under new ownership. Jeff Galdys and his friendly staff are ready to offer you the best pizza in WNY, along with our crispy and saucy wings, fresh salads, and other satisfying menu items. Whether you reside in North Tonawanda, Wheatfield, Amherst, or one of the surrounding areas, count on our pizza and wings restaurant for delicious food whenever you’re hungry!
Based on 204 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 693-7477
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Patrick G
Ordered this today for the second time and we got a large cheese and pep well done with sweet sauce, extra sauce and extra cheese. Pizza was flavorful and made to our specifications. We also ordered some Cajun Honey butter bbq wings and honey BBQ fingers as well. The blue cheese it came with was amazing. The wings blew me away as I usually don’t expect so much from pizzeria wings but they really over delivered in terms of quality and flavor. They could be larger would be my only complaint but they were cooked perfectly once again to our specifications of extra crispy. Fries were crispy and the fingers were a hit as well. Very impressed and we will be ordering from them again! Loved the amount of variety and specifications available to all of their food on the menu and it really stood out how well they listened to those specifications!
… more
Matthew Bellaus
Okay so place is the epitome of don’t judge a book by its cover I pulled up I was like oh man…. But my lunch break ain’t got time to go somewhere else Go inside Nice little place inside talk to the man really nice great guy and the food is absolutely fantastic I’d recommend this over anywhere in the area superb
… more
LuckyZ’s Hero
Everything was pretty alright ,I wish the steak in the Stinger (8″) was not steak um and actual . pizza was a little doughy ,lots of sauce slightly sweet and crispy . pretty decent and the wings were alright. crispy avd saucy. worth a try id say . I ordered delivery everything was boxed fine .stinger was on the pricier end of subs .
… more
Michael Phelps
An absolute diamond seemingly in the rough. Ordered a large half cheese/half pepperoni along with a small pizza with “the works”. Reasonably priced, ready on time, and friendly service. Pizza was phenomenal. Picked it up and drove it all the way back to Hamburg, it was so good, I would make the trip just for those pies again. Fantastic local pizzeria.
… more
Lynn Liebner
Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and 20 wings and spent almost $50 bucks. Asked for the wings crispy they were soggy. The pizza as my boyfriend put it…
… more
Ivan Docenko
This is my first time trying this place. I ordered 1/2 tray half cheese ,half cheese/pepperoni and 30 wings 1/2 honey bbq and 1/2 garlic parm. My first impression, not overly impressed since half the pizza was burnt. I do like the overall taste of the dough ( although a little dry because it was over cooked), the crust had a nice crunch too it though. The cheese has a nice flavor and not too salty like some places can be. The sauce is a sweet sauce, which I liked alot ( I really only like sweeter sauces). Also the pepperoni’s were very nice ,small cup n char but not too thick cut. Overall very good pizza, even though it was burnt. I would definitely try them again. I didn’t bother to try to call to notify them that it was burnt. I’m sure they would have replaced it. We were hungry and just wanted to eat, plus it’s like 15 minutes from my house. The chicken wings were pretty good and cooked crispy like I asked. The honey bbq was very good, it had a different flavor to it that I have never had before. The garlic Parm had a nice flavor to them. However with some of the wings, the sections were not sperated at all. Also my wife says the blue cheese was the best she has had.
… more
Mark Colley
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and traditional wings with mild sauce. The guy that took the order was really helpful and polite. So far, so good. Told us 45-60 minutes and it was here in 50. Good estimate and driver gets good tip.
… more
Erin Thomas
I order a meat lovers pizza for delivery it got to my house in about 15 minutes. The pizza topping where still almost frozen when i called the owner, He never offered to make a new one.
… more
S
Stopped here last night for a pizza. WOW!!! AWESOME!!! Great dough, sauce, toppings, absolutely nothing disappointing with this pizza. Wish I’d of tried this place long ago. I’ll definitely be back very soon. I suggest you try this place out for your next pizza. You’ll be glad you did. I can’t wait to try some other menu items
… more
Jason Eagan
Stopped in for a couple slices. The slices were great. The perfect amount of cheese and sauce, and the crust was perfectly crisp.
… more
… View more