Based on 106 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
510 Westfield Rd, Holyoke, MA 01040
Phone: (413) 437-7021
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gerri-Ann Kozik
Not only are the pizza and hero’s amazing but do yourself the favor of going into the shop to check out their prepared meals/dessert. Right now they have gelato and it is so worth the trip. If you are looking to skip the crazy summer ice cream lines and try something that is delicious and freshly flavored, I highly suggest fat tomatoes!
… more
Brooke Newman
So good definitely recommend the bread. It’s a little spicy on the top though and the pizza was a five out of five. And the cookies were delicious.
… more
Mark
Fat Tomatoes is a hidden gem. I’ve been coming here for a year for their prepared dinners are amazing – better than you’ll have at most restaurants in the area. Not just another pizzeria – excellent Italian food.
… more
Tristan Callan
Some of the best pizza in western Mass and the fried mozzarella squares are out of this world. Best fried mozz I’ve ever had, and really nice house made marinara for dipping. Excellent subs, huge for a good price.
… more
C R
The pizza is delicious but the owner has terrible customer service skills. I ordered via the app and was given a time of 7:17-7:32 for pick up and that I would receive a notification when it was ready. Previous times I have ordered and shown up before getting my notification and have waited. My pizza was sitting on a wire rack when I arrived at 7:40. He placed it in the box added more toppings and handed it to me. The box was cold. When I got home and opened the box the shredded cheese wasn’t even melted. My pizza was cold and when I called to ask if I made a mistake and ordered a cold pizza somehow. I was then told I was 15/20 min late picking up my pizza. He offered to make another one i said “i just want to know the proper temp to reheat it, I don’t want to have to drive back”. I stated that it was cold to the touch, it was 7:46 when I called. He then told me “oh come on, it’s not that cold, it’s probably been a half hour from the time you picked it up” that’s when I said thanks and hung up.
… more
Robert Loughman
I was blown away by the quality of their pizzas! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm atmosphere that immediately put me at ease( I get nervous trying a new pizza place). The staff were incredibly friendly, and they took the time to help me pick the perfect pizza for my taste.
… more
David White
Tried Fat Tomato on a recommendation and it was AMAZING. Best pizza I’ve had in the Holyoke and Easthampton area by far.
… more
Charlie T
One of the best pizzas around!!! Light chewy, crunchy crust. The cheese is DA-LISH!! the toppings are fresh. The sauce is sooo good! Not designed to dine in, but there’s a few tables and the place is spotless.
… more
Max Hallmark
Ok so we ordered 3 pizzas from this place when they opened on Saturday. The owner said I haven’t even turned my oven on yet, 1st warning bell.
… more
E João C
No exaggeration, this is the BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! Desserts and salads in his fridge are delicious and delightful. We tried the grinders once. My wife loved hers, I thought mine was decent but average. The pizza is the real treat here, superior to all other others we have ever tried! I do not recommend ordering from the website. The “Slice” app is terrible, and you get overcharged. Just call in your order if possible.
… more
… View more