Based on 877 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1448 Ety Rd NW, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 652-1111
Website: http://fatcatpizzas.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joey Salyers
We had stopped going here for awhile because it just wasn’t that good. It had been so long we couldn’t remember why so we ordered again and paid for extra sauce. So glad we got extra sauce the alternative would have been none at all. I mean what is going on here? Guess it’s Sugar Bears from here on out thanks for making up my mind for good.
… more
Chris Wells
Been here quite a few times. I think they have a 34″ pizza also. Pizza is sweet tasting & chewy. On a Saturday they had a band playing alot of Eagle songs. Older crowd dancing.
… more
Staci Cain
First time here. I was moderately impressed. We had to ask for service twice. Food came out slow. But there was a live band & it was busy. The band was very loud for a small place. Couldn’t hold a conversation with my family. Overall I will give them another try…..just not on a live band night.
… more
Barb Funk
We all love the sweet taste of Fat Cat Pizza! My adult boys all want Fat Cats when they come back home to Lancaster! Other favorites include deep fried mushrooms, potato skins, pickle spears and the salads are always fresh! Actually I don’t think there are ANY bad menu items at all?! Ample parking, clean restaurant and good service since they first opened! BTW if you haven’t tried their baked lazagna, you are missing out!! It is truly baked to perfection!! BTW, the beer is always COLD and you cannot beat their prices!!! Bar is nice and tv’s are large for game day!! Thank you to Travis who always gives great service!
… more
Erich Davison
I use to love Fat Cat Pizza but the last two times, especially this last time was horrible. The sweet sauce tasted like canned tomato paste loaded with sugar. I ordered a large veggie pizza and it was undercooked and soggy. I assumed the toppings would be freshly sliced and on top the pizza but they were under the cheese which made the toppings undesirable, not to mention the fact that with the toppings hidden underneath the cheese you really can’t tell what all is on it or how much. I loved their sweet house sauce in the past but this time is was way to sweet and way too much sauce on it to the point it was to sweet to eat. I had to let the pizza cool down enough so I could lift the cheese off and scrape off all the sauce and old looking old tasting dices onions that appeared to be pre bagged and diced. I also ordered a small pepperoni pizza. The pepperoni was also underneath the cheese which made it slimy and greasy. I would think pepperoni would be on top so it would become crisp like most people like it. Very disappointing and dissatisfied. F-
… more
Nikki Blake
The service was awful. When I finally got to talk to someone she was rude. It took 40 min before someone came to our table. The only reason we stayed was because the band The Blues hounds was so good.
… more
Jana Griffin
Good food and Pizza, great music with Double Barrel Band and reasonable prices! You won’t be disappointed!
… more
Jonathan Bukey
I’ve heard really great things about the pizza here so we finally tried it. It was extremely disappointing. The presentation and feel of the pizza was promising, as it looked fresh and made of quality dough. However, the flavor was almost non-existent. I guess the sauce was sweet, but it really had no flavor or was maybe barely there. I didn’t ask, but there was no shaker for pepper flakes or parmesan on the table. I’ve never had such a bland pizza in my life. The wings we ordered were very good. I had traditional hot wings, and they had plenty of kick and were decently sized. My wife ordered boneless wings that were consistent and fried well. The one positive note about the pizza was it wasn’t greasy at all and this applied to the wings as well. The server was really friendly and helped get us squared away quickly when we suddenly had to leave for a family emergency. She even offered to-go cups since she knew we were going to be traveling.
… more
McKenzie Dewese
We love fat cats pizza and their other food- in the past we never have had issues with seating or being served, and we have hosted parties a couple times there. However, in the past 2 months we have tried to order over the phone 5 separate occasions and no one has answered the phone any of those times. This has been various days of the week at various times. We have even tried waiting 30 mins to an hour to call back with no luck.
… more
Eli hall
Never ate here befor the Service was good. Friendly
… more
… View more