ENJOY A MEAL IN NEWBURGH, IN
Chow down at a combination pizzeria and sandwich shop
Looking to try something new for dinner? Order up some classic thin-crust pizza at Fat Boy’s Pizza Newburgh. Our pizzeria churns out pie after delicious pie, topped with sizzling, savory sauce and fresh ingredients.
All of our pizzas are thin-crust and made-to-order using only the freshest ingredients. Our pizza is carry-out only, but we do offer delivery through Door Dash. You can get pizza for your event or have it delivered to your home for dinner. Call 812-518-3061 now to order a pizza from a pizzeria in Newburgh, IN.
Based on 204 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
10722 IN-662, Newburgh, IN 47630
Phone: (812) 518-3061
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday |
3–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday |
10 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
10 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Friday |
10 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tony Kiegel
The sauce was pungent and cheese wasn’t good. The breadsticks were worse than Fazolis and came with a cold dipping cup of nacho cheese. It’s hard to ruin a pizza but this restaurant has it figured out for $60.
… more
Melanie J Watkins
This is the first time my husband and I tried their pizza. Absolutely one of the best in town! The crust is thin but has a chew to it, which I love! They load it with toppings and real mozzarella cheese, but that sauce! Omgsh, I don’t know what they do to it, but it’s incredible! I highly recommend their pizza! It’s outstanding, and if you have read my reviews, I rarely state that. Unbeatable flavor and toppings! I’m just so shocked that it has beat the others by far!! We’re definitely getting our pizza here from here on! Great job, Fat Boy’s !
… more
Ryan Brothers
I ordered around 5:15, was told it would be half an hour, and still not ready at 6:30. Ridiculous. Other people getting food and leaving that I’m sure ordered after me. Not going to return, with service like that!
… more
Brian Allen
I tried to call my normal go to for Strombolis (even thoughthey’ve really gone downhill lately) but the they wouldn’t answer & when they finally did I was put on hold & finally hung up after 8 minutes. Tried Fat Boys for the first time instead & was not disappointed. This will be my new go to for Strombolis. Sounds like I need to try their pizza too. Very pleased.
… more
Tabitha Thurman
If you’re ordering pizza in Newburgh IN or the surrounding area, my boyfriend and I highly recommend ordering from here. Their pizza is our absolute favorite. Not only do we love the food, their customer service is always so wonderful and helpful. If you’re seeing this review because you are considering ordering from Fat Boys, place the order!! You won’t regret it!
… more
Brandon Greene
Ok on the thin pizza scale of 10 being Spankeys and 1 Cici’s. We had the Meat Lovers, Pepperoni, and Buffalo Wings. I give it a 7-1/2 to 8. The pizza sauce is a flavorful tomatoe base . The toppings were hardy, and the cheese is very tasty. The cheese to meat ratio is adequate and they don’t skimp on the amount of either that they load onto the pizza. The wings were baked and have a spicy, but not hot sauce. Overall, the experience was very good with Great customer service.
… more
jason machen
Pretty good pizza, decent deals during the week. You call in, order, call again when you pick up, and they bring it out. Pretty good overall experience. Will probably order again.
… more
Mike Murphy
Ordered three small pizzas and was told it would be 35 min. When I arrived was met out front by employee as you cannot go inside. Told her my name, she came back and told me no such order and wanted to know if I wanted to reorder. This was my first and last time to this establishment.
… more
None Required
Loved the pizza! The crispness in the crust was absolutely perfect! Bee. Wanting to try their pizza for a while. I recommend if you love delicious pizza that you try this immediately. Friendly staff, small location so it is not dine-in. I ordered pepperoni and beef. The ingredients tasted very fresh. 5 stars!
… more
David Nguyen
Great place to pick up pizza and wings! Crumbled sausage will taste good with most toppings.
… more
… View more
