Home of the Panino! A unique flatbread sandwich filled with lean meats & cheeses, baked to perfection, topped with fresh veggies and tasty sauces. Our Buffalo Chicken Panino was chosen as the Pizza Expo 365 Sandwich Challenge Winner! Also serving a delicious array of Appetizers, Pastas, Rice Bowls, Salads & voted St. Peter’s Best Pizza! Kid’s menu. Serving Beer & Wine. To join our MVP Club & get your first Panino FREE message ‘PANINO’ to our Facebook page @ExtraInningsSP
Based on 82 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
220 S Minnesota Ave, St Peter, MN 56082
Phone: (507) 934-4326
Website: https://www.extrainningspaninos.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lillie Hagen
I’ve been here three times so far and it’s been amazing each time! The restaurant is nice and clean. The staff is amazing and so kind to us when we visit! I love the eco friendly steps they are making as well, it is so nice to see that in a small town. The food is delicious! The chicken alfredo panino is my favorite so far. I’m excited to keep coming back and trying new things. Also, I appreciate the panino punchcards they have! Even more reason to come back. Thanks for bringing something new and fresh to Saint Peter!
… more
Trish Groendyk
My husband and I found this place on our way to Minneapolis. It is spotless. The thin crust pizza was delicious and the Chicken Alfredo pocket was even better. Staff was great as well. Highly recommend giving it a try.
… more
Marcy Lorentz
Tried buffalo panini today. It was delicious. The service was friendly and polite. The atmosphere was inviting. Definitely going again, but next time I’ll need to be prepared for the cardboard straw (only complaint and that’s pretty minor).
… more
Ramiro Alvarez
Obviously, the people that gave this place a positive review are either fake accounts or friends of the owner. The pizza was a step below frozen pizza. And I’ve had boneless chicken wings but I’ve never had chickenless chicken wings. I hope you all improve your offerings and stick around. Good luck.
… more
Terri Stratton.hickey
Nice variety on their menu. Was made fresh and very delicious! Inside seating was nice, love the old brick walls. But, the service was outstanding! Prompt. Super cordial. Nice manners. I recommend others to give it a try!!
… more
Ryan Theissen
Amazing food, literally everything we have tried has been delicious. Service was great! I cannot recommend this place enough! Best pizza around there’s no comparison!
… more
Wendy Weller
Very good. We had a coupon so thought we would try it. The Reuben Panino was very good. Wait was longer then “pre-pandemic” where isn’t it. Plus, this is a not a fast food place. Better quality food takes longer. Staff was very apologetic for the wait, even though it was fine. They still gave us another coupon for the wait. Plenty of TV’s to keep up with whatever sport you want to watch. Good experience.
… more
Julie Lundy
I wouldn’t recommend ♀️ there was very little meat in our meal. Food is just average. No music going, we were the only ones in there, and it smelled like someone has been smoking in there too.
… more
Delores Sievers
We did not have a very pleasant experience here. For $10.00, I got a bag of chips with my 1/2 philly steak sandwich that consisted of very little meat wrapped in the toughest bread I’ve ever had. I could barely chew it. Two other people in my party ordered the taco salad which was made up of only lettuce, meat, black olives, tomato and cheese. There was NO taco seasoning flavor at all but salt…there was a lot of salt In the meat. Not a very good experience or meal for the money. We were going to speak to the staff but could not get anyone’s attention.
… more
Douglas Crosby
The food was quite good, quick service. The server was very helpful to new visitors; answering a couple questions I had, checked in on how we were liking our food, took trays away. Overall very good experience, would go there again!
… more
… View more