This old-fashioned Italian restaurant with white tablecloths offers an array of traditional dishes. Based on 372 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
4000 William Penn Hwy, Monroeville, PA 15146
Phone: (412) 372-4414
Website: https://www.nickmariesestaesta.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jet Black
We stopped in based on Google reviews and didn’t expect much but BOY were we surprised! The fried Parmesan was probably the best I’ve ever had, the NY strip was cooked to a perfect medium rare throughout, with a beautiful char. Tracy was the only server, but she was the consummate pro—amazing how calm, warm, and hospitable she was able to be with so many tables! People clearly love her, and I can see why. Highly recommend!!!
… more
D Christie
Dined here last night with two friends for the first time and I must say it was excellent. The decor is older but that adds to the experience. The waitress whose name I think is Tracey was exceptional. I had wedding soup and lasagna but sampled my friends chicken marsala and shrimp scampi linguine. The green goddess dressing a friend suggested was amazing. We will be back soon. Highly recommend trying this place.
… more
Jennifer Depanicis
Italian cusine as well as many other options, tried the stuffed salmon special. Was tasty, also friendly waitresses, nice for a group.
… more
Tracey’s Footprints
We just had an amazing birthday dinner with family & friends. Tracey was an awesome Server and all the food was exceptional (with only one dish [Shrimp Barsac] a bit overcooked and not that fabulous. Honestly the very best zucchini appetizer and the Hummingbird cake was the best dessert I’ve had in eons (a mix between banana cake, pineapple upside cake and carrot cake!!!). Very highly recommended and we will for sure return again!
… more
Maureen Monhollen
Old world Italian with a lot more than pasta. The interior is dark and cozy, if a little dated and tired, but the food was exceptional. My server, Cassie, was friendly and knowledgeable. I’ll definitely be back.
… more
V. Perelman
This is a restaurant that I could see Tony Soprano eating at with Carmella! I loved the food, the decor, and the service! The building may be dated but that truly adds to the ambiance of a family owned restaurant that obviously is focused on quality food and a very tasty marinara sauce that was superb! Please do not change your decor, the building location or the menu! Definitely check this place out for authentic Italian!
… more
Ramsie Quinlin
Me and my boyfriend visited from Baltimore, MD and when the Cheesecake Factory was packed, we were on the hunt for another fine dining. This place was beautiful and elegant. EXTREMELY affordable. Discovered my favorite wine too! We sat at the bar for a bit as well and it felt like a classy old time bar. The woman who served us were sweet and attentive. Was delicious and my boyfriend being picky, was impressed.
… more
Brandon Mike Sparrow
When going in there was nobody to seat me due to they were not busy. I went into the bar and had someone seat me. They were extremely apologetic and were very nice. The waitress was also very nice, attentive, and very polite. The place did have a musty odor but not bad. The wedding soup was flavorful. The bread seemed like it was sitting out all day but not bad. The salad was ok. The sausage stuffed banana peppers were decent. The lasagna was not bad and the portion was small. The meatballs I wasn’t too impressed with. The spaghetti was not bad and it was a decent portion. All in all I wasn’t very impressed with the food. However I was impressed with the wait staff.
… more
Susie Wilden
I had our work Christmas party here and everyone loved the food! The chicken parmigiana was delicious and always is! The wedding soup was really tasty. The shrimp scampi dinner had big shrimp and the sauce was just the perfect amount of seasoning. Tammy at the bar made a nice cocktail before dinner and we loved the atmosphere. Must try!
… more
Onyx
Absolutely incredible. There was a bit of a wait but the service did not suffer from it. The food was the best Italian I’ve had in a long time. Will definitely come back again
… more
… View more