Based on 100 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone: (631) 725-5668
Social Profile:
Hours
Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alessandra Fusco
The food is good, but the customer service was awful. I ordered a sandwich and when I got home, I realized I received something completely different from what I ordered. I called and explained and asked if I could come back to swap it out. As soon as I got back to swap out the sandwich, the woman aggressively and accusatorily pointed at me and told me that I ordered wrong and continued to argue with me. She kept telling me that I ordered number 16, not 68 and was incredibly rude about it. I knew what I wanted and what I ordered, and it could’ve easily been misunderstood. It was so upsetting and uncomfortable that I told them to forget about the sandwich and I wanted, and I took the wrong order and left and will definitely not be going back there. If you do plan on ordering from there, make sure you tell them what you want and don’t just give them the number on the menu. I just wasted time and money on food that is going to be thrown out and a really upsetting experience.
… more
Joey Salsedo
This place is absolutely rancid, and completely destroys the former espresso glory. Food is improperly cared for with little to no standards. A soulless fabrication of a business that really needs to close up shop. The family who owns this is nasty to their customers with horrible attitudes blaming the public for their misgivings. From raw meatballs to expired chicken, yes, expired chicken that has given half this town food poisoning, is treacherous and should never be trifled with. They also find any possible way to charge extra for dressings which has gone so far down hill that it bastardizes the iconic gold it once was. I would advise people to avoid at all costs. Would rather eat the Sahara desert, cause hey the chicken is not too far off.
… more
Paul Gamble
First-time customer. Ordered the lasagna della nonna and the penne broccoli rabe. Absolutely delicious!!! Ideal location to pick up dinner on the way into town on a weekend. Parking behind the restaurant makes it a convenient stop.
… more
Samantha Gilly
This place used to be so good! I will never eat here again! They started really skimping on the portions, but despite that we still got it. We came last night and got a sandwich with prosciutto on it. The meat was rancid! We actually threw up! We took the meat off the sandwich and you could totally tell it went bad a while ago! The smell and taste and look was horrible. Beyond disappointing.
… more
Mr. Kye
I was planning on emailing the business directly but there doesn’t seem to be a way to do that via their website.
… more
Jerry LaMadrid
3 sandwiches and 1 cheese ravioli meal for $85. The sandwiches were lack luster and dry, the ravioli were swimming is tomato soup and the service was non-existent. Unhappy employees making sad food makes for a bad recipe.
… more
Pawel Skonieczny
Great food , great people , highly recommend!!!
… more
elizabeth blankenship
I had the misfortune of finding this place for a cup of coffee while on vacation. The cashier was rude and disrespectful. In addition, I have had better instant coffee than what I received at this establishment. Don’t waste your time or money.
… more
R Kelly
fresh eats good food service great…
… more
Rachel Moyer
Normally I love Espresso’s pizza but last night was the worst I had. Ordered 2 slices & it was so burnt, and the whole pizza & crust was so hard.
… more
… View more