Based on 126 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
170 Chestnut St, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone: (973) 320-2339
Website: http://emilioswfp.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
| Sunday | 1–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Colin Nisbet
Came by myself, and as soon as I entered I was very politely greeted with a big smile and a welcome. Great first impression! I asked for suggestions and could tell the server was very passionate about the food which is always a good sign. Music was well selected and at an appropriate volume.
… more
Jen
Came for a late lunch yesterday and I loved everything! The bough is just perfect and their tomato sauce was !
… more
Valentina Nova
This spot was recommended by a friend and after trying it I cannot say enough good things. As a Neapolitan pizza fan, post moving to Jersey from NYC I had struggled to find a good spot but this is it. Passing it it looks very unassuming but don’t let that fool you. Upon walking in the small space is very cozy and clean. Everyone is friendly and there’s a vibe of comfort and good times. The owner approached us and the other customers just making sure our food and service were good which they most definitely were. On this occasion we just grabbed a margherita pie as a barometer of comparison to other pies I’d had and it was scrumptious. Every bite was so flavorful and fresh, I felt healthy eating pizza! I did catch some other fun pies on the menu that I’m dying to try. Overall, this is a win in my book and a great way to support quality local businesses!
… more
Nicole Gary
It’s like enjoying a pizza with family and friends in the kitchen. The pies have the freshest ingredients I have every had on a pie at a restaurant. Hot honey pepperoni pie. Pepperoni covered the entire pie, creating small cups, that held the perfect amount of hot honey. Fra diavolo lots of hot peepers and large leaves of fresh basil. They grow their herbs, dough ingredients are imported and the pie price is affordable.
… more
Michael Kouyoumdjian
Best pizza around in my opinion. Family run serving napoletana pizza with the freshest seasonal ingredients. You will not be disappointed! We will definitely be back!
… more
Luca De Simone
Prologue: I am Neapolitan. Born and raised. I ate in many pizzerie that are considered amazing in Napoli.
… more
D Magnus
if Google raised their star ratings and allowed for 10 stars, Emilio’s would get 11!
… more
Ashley Vidals
Dined in tonight with my husband and loved everything! From the moment you walk in you are welcomed with attentive and friendly staff. The appetizers were great, the Margerita and Bianca e Verde pizzas were *chef’s kiss* and dessert is a must! They have great offerings I have not seen in any other pizzeria/restaurant. My husband and I tried the Manhattan Special drink, it is an espresso coffee soda, we loved it! I recommend trying their desserts but you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. All the ingredients tasted fresh. The owner, Rafael, even offered us fresh mozzarella that he had just made! Amazing customer service, will definitely be returning soon to try the rest of the menu!
… more
Loretta pontes amaral
Went to Emilio’s with my Fiancée and my baby today (Sunday). It was our third time! We come all the way from Linden and it is totally worth the drive! The pizza is absolutely a killer!!! Very flavorful, fresh and light! The atmosphere and service are top notch!
… more
Hector Barrero
A Hidden Gem in Nutley NJ atmosphere is great food is Excellent the owner is always greating you with a smile, definitely BYOD a nice wine to pair with your pizza
… more
… View more