El Compadre Menu – Paoli, IN

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Paoli, IN

Based on 470 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

El Compadre 47454

Address:
162 S Court St #1367, Paoli, IN 47454

Phone: (812) 723-0340

Website: https://www.elcompadremexicanindiana.com/

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Antojitos / Appetizers
Jalapeno Poppers (6) $3.99
Cheese Dip $2.79
Bean Dip $2.49
Guacamole Dip $2.49
Nachos With Cheese $3.29
Nachos With Cheese And Beef $4.29
Nachos With Beans $3.89
Nachos With Beans And Beef $4.89
Chicken And Rice
Grilled chicken strips on top a bed of rice topped with cheese sauce		 $6.99
Supreme Nachos
Beans, beef, lettuce, cheese, sour cream, and tomato		 $6.79
Cheese Quesadilla $2.89
Quesedilla (Chicken Or Beef)
Cooked with onions, peppers and tomatoes		 $2.89
Cheese Fries $2.99
Crispy Hot Wings
Served with a dish of cheese sauce		 $5.99
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and cheese		 $5.99
Mexican Vegetarians
Chalupa, Cheese Enchilada And Beans $6.29
Quesadilla, Bean Burrito And Rice $6.29
Two Bean Burritos With Cheese And Salad $6.29
Vegetarian Fajitas With Mushrooms
Served with lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo, rice, beans, and tortillas		 $9.39
American Favorites
Double Cheeseburger $7.49
Chicken Sandwich $7.49
Chicken Tenders (4) $7.49
Create Your Own Combo
Enchilada
Chalupa
Tostada
Chimichanga
Cheese Quesadilla
Taco
Burrito
Taquito
Tamale
Comida Del Mar / Seafood
Shrimp Fajitas
Served with guacamole, pico de gallo, rice, beans, sour cream and flour tortillas		 $12.49
Shrimp Quesadilla
A flour tortilla grilled and stuffed with shrimp, bell pepper, onion, tomato, and cheese. Served with rice, lettuce, sour cream and tomato		 $8.99
Camarones Endiablados Hot!
Shrimp cooked in red sauce. Served with rice, beans, and flour tortilla		 $9.49
Camarones A La Mexicana
Shrimp and mushrooms cooked with onions, cilantro, then covered in cheese. Served with pico de gallo, tortillas, beans and rice		 $12.49
Shrimp Taco Salad
Grilled shrimp cooked with bell peppers, tomato and onions. Garnished with lettuce, cheese, sour cream, guacamole, and tomatoes		 $11.99
Shrimp Chimichanga
One flour tortilla stuffed with shrimp, deep fried and topped with cheese sauce, lettuce, sour cream, guacamole and pico de gallo. Served with rice and beans.		 $9.49
Shrimp Nachos Fajita
Cooked with onions, tomatoes, and bell peppers topped with lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and cheese		 $11.49
Comidas / Dinners
Two Burritos, Rice And Beans $7.49
One Enchilada, Burrito, Rice, And Beans $7.49
One Enchilada, Burrito And Tamale $7.49
Two Beef Enchiladas, Rice And Salad $7.49
One Chicken And One Beef Enchilada, Rice And Beans $7.49
Taco, Burrito And Rice $7.49
Chimichanga, Tostada And Rice $7.49
Taco, Two Enchiladas And Beans $7.49
One Enchilada, Chile Relleno, Rice And Beans $7.49
Three Beef Tacos, Rice And Beans $7.49
Lista De Precios En Extra / Add Ons
Shrimp (6 Pieces) $3.50
Chorizo $3.50
Mushrooms $1.75
Pineapple $1.25
Bacon $2.00
Shrimp Chimichanga $5.75
Grilled Vegetables $1.75
Taquito $1.85
Extra Cheese Sauce On Top $1.50
Extra Meat For Taco Salad $1.50
Fajita – Extra Beef Or Chicken $3.99
Grilled Chicken Or Steak $3.99
Rib $1.75
Double Cheeseburger $4.99
Cheesburger $3.29
Chicken Sandwich $4.99
Chicken Sandwich $3.50
Chicken Breast $5.50
Fajita Plate Salad $4.99
Whole Avocado $2.25
El Compadre / Specialties
El Big Combo “A Little Bit Of $ Everything”
One taco, one enchilada, one tostada, one tamale, one chile relleno with rice and beans		 $10.99
Enchiladas Verdes
Three chicken enchiladas topped with green tomatillo sauce, salad and rice		 $6.99
Enchiladas Regias
Two chicken and two beef enchiladas topped with lettuce, tomato, cheese and sour cream		 $7.29
La Chimichanga (1)
One flour tortilla stuffed with your choice of beef or chicken, cooked with onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes, then deep-fried and topped with cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, sour cream, tomato, rice and beans		 $7.25
Dos Chimichangas (2)
Two fried burritos (beef or chicken cooked with onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes) topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans		 $8.29
El Burrito Norteno
A flour tortilla filled with your choice of ground beef or chicken topped with lettuce, cheese sour cream and tomato. Served with rice and beans		 $7.99
El Burrito Special
One burrito served with your choice of seasoned beef or chicken topped with sauce, lettuce, cheese, sour cream and tomato		 $4.99
Goya’s Special
Two burritos with your choice of seasoned beef or chicken topped with lettuce, cheese, sour cream and tomato		 $7.99
Monterrey Special
Two poblano peppers stuffed with cheese wrapped in eggs, deep fried, topped with beef and salsa. Served with rice and salsa		 $9.99
Chicken Or Beef Taquitos
Four rolled corn tortillas stuffed with shredded beef or chicken served with lettuce, sour cream, tomato and rice		 $7.99
Taco Salad
A crispy flour tortilla shell covered with chicken breast or seasoned ground beef and garnished with lettuce, cheese, sour cream and tomato		 $6.89
Chilaquiles
Tortilla chips cooked in red or green sauce topped with chicken or beef and cheese. Served with rice and beans		 $6.79
Chile Rojo
Chunks of pork meat in homemade red sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $6.99
A La Plancha / From the Grill
Fajitas Cancun
Steak, chicken, or both		 $9.99
Fajitas Pepe’s
Steak, chicken, shrimp and chorizo		 $13.99
Fajitas Yola’s
Steak, chicken and shrimp		 $12.99
Hawaiian Fajitas
Steak, chicken, mushrooms, melted cheese & Pineapple		 $11.99
Taco Salad Fajita
A crispy flour tortilla covered with grilled steak or chicken, fajita style, garnished with lettuce, guacamole, cheese, sour cream, and tomato. No beans		 $9.29
Nachos Fajitas
Cheese nachos with your choice of grilled beef steak, chicken strips or both, garnished with lettuce, cheese, sour cream, and tomato		 $9.59
Tijuana’s Steak
T-bone steak topped with bell peppers, onions and tomato. Served with rice and beans and corn or flour tortillas (12 oz.)		 $12.99
Ranchero Steak Hot!
T-bone steak topped with 5 shrimp and red sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $15.99
Gringo Special
T-bone steak served with fries and rice		 $12.29
Norteño Steak
T-bone topped with cheese and enchilada sauce, rice, beans and tortillas		 $12.99
Carne Azada
Tender ribeye steak topped with grilled onion. Served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $12.99
Vero’s Special
Three steak tacos, salad, pico de gallo and green tomato sauce		 $7.99
Burrito Mexicano
Big burrito stuffed with chopped steak, beans, lettuce, sour cream and tomato. Topped with cheese and sauce		 $7.99
Pollo Loco
Mexican seasoning, grilled chicken breast served with rice, beans, tortillas, and salad		 $9.99
Pepe’s Jr
Grilled chicken strips, sauteed onions, bell pepper and cilantro topped with cheese. Served with rice, beans, and tortillas		 $9.99
Chicken Veracruz
Grilled chicken breast topped with cheese and enchilada sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $9.49
Chicken Acapulco
Grilled chicken strips cooked with onions, bell peppers and bacon, then topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and sour cream salad		 $11.49
Lunch Specials
Un Taco
Crispy corn tortilla stuffed with your choice of fillings, lettuce and cheese. Served with Mexican rice and beans		 $3.59
Tamale
Tender beef wrapped in an authentic soft corn shell, topped with seasoned beef and red sauce. Served with rice and beans		 $3.79
Quick Lunch
One taco, one enchilada and your choice of beans or rice		 $4.29
La Chimichanga (1)
One flour tortilla stuffed with your choice of beef or chicken, deep fried and topped with cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, sour cream, tomato, rice and beans		 $5.29
El Chile Relleno
Chile Relleno, rice and salad		 $4.99
Vegetarian
Cheese quesadilla, rice and beans		 $3.79
Taco Salad
A crispy flour tortilla shell covered with season ground beef or chicken breast, garnished with lettuce, cheese, sour cream, and tomato. No beans.		 $4.49
Enchilada
A soft corn tortilla stuffed with your choice of fillings covered with enchilada sauce. Served with Mexican rice and beans		 $3.79
La Tostada
A flat, crispy corn tortilla covered with beef, lettuce, cheese, sour cream, and tomato. Served with rice and beans		 $4.29
Taquitos Mexicanos
Two corn tortillas wrapped around your favorite fillings, deep fried, and served with lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo. Served with rice and beans		 $4.79
Burrito
One beef burrito, Mexican rice and beans		 $4.29
El Combo
Beef burrito, one taco, and Mexican rice		 $4.79
Las Fajitas
Tender grilled strips of marinated chicken breast or beef steak served on a sizzling platter with sauteed onions, bell peppers, and tomato. Garnished with lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, and pico de gallo. Served with corn or flour tortillas, refired beans, and Mexican rice		 $6.79
Huevos Con Chorizo
Three scrambled eggs cooked with Mexican sausage. Served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $6.99
A La Carte
Sour Cream $0.99
Chile Relleno $3.50
Tamale $1.95
Beef Tostada $2.70
Chimichanga (Chicken Or Beef) $3.29
Shredded Cheese $0.99
Enchilada $1.85
Soft Taco $1.89
Hard Taco $1.59
Sour Cream Salad $1.50
Tomatoes $0.99
Steak Taco (Plain) $2.25
Grilled Chicken Or Steak Quesadilla $3.69
Mushroom Quesadilla $3.69
Rice $1.29
Beans $1.29
Chalupa $2.50
Burrito
bean, beef, chicken or cheese		 $2.95
Jalepenos $0.99
Corn Or Flour Tortilla $0.99
Pico De Gallo $1.49
Guacamole Salad $1.99
Tossed Salad $2.50
Salad $1.25
French Fries $1.89
South of the Border Specials
Taco Single
Pastor- Marinated Pork; Chicharron- Pork rinds cooked in green sauce; Carne azada- Grilled Steak; Pollo azada- Grilled Chicken; Carnitas- Pork Steamed. All tacos served with corn tortillas, cilantro, and onions		 $1.99
Mole
Chicken breast cooked in homemade red salsa served with rice, beans and tortillas		 $6.99
Carnitas
Pork steamed and served with rice, beans, lettuce, tomatoes and corn tortillas		 $9.29
Cocktel De Camaron
Shrimp Cocktail: Shrimp mixed with tomato sauce and pico de gallo served with crackers		 $12.09
Chipotle BBQ Ribs
A generous portion of St. Louis style pork ribs smoked and topped with chipotle BBQ sauce. Served with French fries or rice and beans		 $9.49
Corona Fish
Two pieces of Corona beer batter tilapia. Served with rice, lettuce, tomato, and sour cream		 $8.99
Sopes
Thick corn tortilla served with favorite topping and beans garnished with lettuce, cheese, sour cream, and tomatoes. Pastor- Marinated Pork; Chicharron- Pork rinds cooked in green sauce; Carne azada- Grilled Steak; Carne molida- Ground beef		 $2.79
Torta (Mexican Sandwich)
Made from Telera (Mexican roll). Served with your favorite fillings. Stuffed with beans, sour cream, lettuce, tomatoes, guacamole, shredded cheese, and mayo. Served with chips		 $7.99
Kid’s Favorites
Small Taco Salad $3.69
One Cheese Quesadilla, Rice And Beans $3.69
One Enchilada, Rice And Beans $3.69
Cheeseburger With Fries $4.29
Chicken Sandwich With Fries $4.29
Chicken Tenders (2) With Fries $4.29
One Taco, Rice And Beans $3.69
One Burrito, Rice And Beans $3.69
Chicken Nuggets (6) With Fries $4.29
Desserts
Flan (Mexican Custard)
Traditional Mexico-style creme caramel		 $2.79
Bunuelo (Elephant Ear) $2.09
Bunuelo With Ice Cream
Topped with honey, cinnamon, and chocolate		 $2.59
Fried Ice Cream $2.79
Chimichanga Feliz
Stuffed with apple filling and served with vanilla ice cream, whip cream, chocolate and strawberry syrup		 $3.59
Cheesecake Chimichanga
Deep fried burrito stuffed with cheesecake filling and topped with cinnamon and sugar, two scoops strawberry/vanilla ice cream, whipped cream and strawberry and chocolate syrup		 $3.79
Drinks
Coke $1.79
Diet Coke $1.79
Mr. Pibb $1.79
Mello Yello $1.79
Sprite $1.79
Lemonade $1.79
Root Beer $1.79
Fanta Orange $1.79
Iced Tea $1.79
Coffee (Limit 2 Refills) $1.19
Strawberry Daiquiri (Non Alcoholic)
no refills		 $2.99
Pina Colada (Non Alcoholic)
no refills		 $2.99
Description of Mexican Plates
Tacos (Tah-Kos)
Tortilla folded and fried crisp, filled with beef, lettuce & cheese
Quesadilla
Flour tortilla filled with cheese, fried in butter
Guacamole (Wah-Hah-Mo-Lay)
Avocado Salad
Beef Tostada (Tohs-Tah-Dah)
Flat tortilla with beef, lettuce, cheese and tomato
Tamales (Tah-Mah-Lays)
Savory meat fillings steamed in corn meal casings
Chimichangas (Chi-Mee-Chan-Ganz)
Beef or chicken burrito, deep fried and topped with cheese sauce
Chile Relleno (Chee-Lay Ray-Yah-Noz)
Peppers stuffed with cheese, wrapped in eggs and deep fried

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

C. Morgan
Having visited quite a few mexican restaurants, I have to say this is as good as many. Nothing on the menu is unique, however the food was as good as you would expect from a restaurant of this style. The staff are friendly and attentive. The “music” of you will is authentic, however today it seemed to be a talk radio program or a television ran through the speakers. Food came up quick, beans were of the canned variety as with many mexican restaurants. The rice was good. My chicken Tamale was pretty good. Chicken was slightly on the dry side. Price was fair. Overall, a decent experience.

… more

chandler Ikerd
Absolutely terrible service, chicken and rice was completely dry with zero queso, even after informing the waitress to make sure there was queso on it because I have had the same problem here before. After informing the waiter about the problem when it came out dry they charged me for a whole queso again. Just terrible service all around and barely got refills. Would not recommend, save your time and money and go to hacienda by tractor supply!

… more

steven bosley
Order was fast, accurate and tasty. Service was acceptable not great. They were quite busy, so I’m sure Service reflects that. I go there about once every couple months. Get carry out about same frequency. So I probably eat there monthly. There chips salsa and queso is a must when dining in. Chips are often still hot.

… more

Kristin Williams
The food is amazing. The service is not the best when it comes to delivery! Their system does not show the correct information and then there is the issue where I have an email confirming an order with delivery but being told by the restaurant there is no order. I will never go to the place again with all the issues I have had!!

… more

Circuit Court
The food is great, best crunchy tacos in my opinion. Service is sometimes great and sometimes mediocre. Atmosphere is ok maybe pretty authentic. I like this place especially for lunch. I like the quick lunch special.

… more

KJ Wojciechowski
Pretty great Mexican place for the middle of nowhere Indiana. Good food, and really reasonable prices. They even have $1 Taco Tuesdays, and the tacos are delicious. Today we also shared a seafood mocajete with cactus, and it was very tasty.

… more

Cathy Keibler
Situated on the square in Paoli, In. this was a bright, cheerful oasis on a rainy Wednesday evening. We were seated immediately. The menu is large and varied. With combo platters, meals and vegetarian offerings, there is something for everyone. We started with the special guacamole. This is guac dressed up to go to town! With diced tomatos, onions, peppers and the avocado diced instead of mashed. A lovely and tasty presentation. The house salsas were fresh and flavorful. For my meal I had the California burrito, featuring shredded pork, rice, beans, bell peppers and onions and dressed with queso and green sauce. This burrito was giant! Stuffed with fresh ingredients, lightly spiced and delicious. I was able to eat only half, despite my best efforts! Accompanying the meal I had a lime margarita on ice, just the right balance if sweet and sour. There is a full bar. Service was friendly and prompt. This will be a new destination for us!

… more

Jeff Parrott
I wasn’t impressed with the food. The seasoned beef had hardly any flavor. Service wasn’t great either. We won’t be back.

… more

Denise Van Gilder
Food is really good. Service wasn’t great but not too bad. Portions are generous

… more

Tracy Archer
I just love coming here for the atmosphere as well as the food. Alexis usually waits on us and she is amazing as well as Tony who is the Manager. We always sit on the bar side because it is a lot quieter. I have been ordering the tacos lately with the hard shells and they have been really good. My husband doesn’t have anything in particular that he gets. They do have the best margaritas, though. I usually order a half pitcher on the rocks with a straw, no glass

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Hacienda El Asadero Menu – Paoli, IN
  2. El Taco Loco #2 Menu – Albuquerque, NM
  3. Taqueria Sin Frontera Menu – Tulare, CA
  4. Postre Cafe Menu – Layton, UT

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch