Based on 300 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
9 Main St, Sussex, NJ 07461
Phone: (973) 875-3000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Steve Basanyi
Good choices for food. The meatloaf and burgers could’ve used a little salt, but I’d rather add salt than it being to salty! HALF PRICE APPS AFTER 9PM. GREAT DEAL!!
… more
Shannon Berlinski
Food was mediocre. My sandwich was a special & didn’t have much brisket on it. It was more of a hoagie bread sandwich. That is all I tasted. My husbands 1/2 rack of ribs were an extremely small portion. Not worth $22!
… more
Brett Matak
Fun night out. Large tables so tables of 6 are easy to seat. The service and food were good. Always a festive atmosphere. The sweet potato fries are super yum and I really enjoyed the prime rib sandwich.
… more
Rick Rios
food and service was good ..people awesome … once did take a lil long for the food to come out BUT it was ok
… more
kaylee
Early American Tavern has earned my personal “Best BLT” award. My sister loved her pizza, my mother loved the French onion soup. Everything was great about this place, especially the fact that the entertainment (a band at the time I was there) wasn’t at all overpowering. I do recommend it!
… more
Kim Shaw
We went to Early American Tavern last night on my birthday. There were 13 of us. I just want to say we had the best time ever. The food and the service were exceptional! Heather you were amazing! The menu is diverse and sumptuous. Drinks were in front of us before you could blink your eye. We ordered a lot of food and it all came out perfect and timely. Best of all the bill was reasonable, and trust me, we ate and drank a ton! Thank you again for an amazing 3 hours. We will most certainly be back.
… more
Chelsea Metzgar
I came here for lunch and let me just say there is NOTHING else like this in Sussex. The food was absolutely amazing, they have so much variety and clearly worked very hard on the menu. Not to mention the waitress/bartender was an absolute doll, friendly, kind and provided EXCEPTIONAL service. I can’t wait to come back I’m definitely looking forward to it!!
… more
Tammy Liebe
Went tonight for our second time because we received an offer for BOGO wings. The first time we had entrees that were really good so we wanted to go back to try some pub food. The wings were excellent!!! So BIG, crispy, and the flavor of the teriyaki and garlic parm was great. Our server and everyone was so friendly. Can’t wait to go back and try more things. Nice relaxed rustic atmosphere.
… more
Elsie Santana
The food and staff are great . We go to the Early American Tavern a lot in groups off 10 people we never had a problem .You may have a long wait for food but is worth it .Wednesday Bingo night is a most lots of fun good drinks and food.
… more
D M
Food is quite tasty. Burgers are delicious and juicy. Calzones are perfectly cooked and big enough to feed 2 or 3 people. Many other great tasting items was well.
… more
… View more