Based on 246 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
50 Public Square, Holley, NY 14470
Phone: (585) 638-5440
Website: http://dustinspizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mike Ehrhardt
Dustin’s is a small town piece of shop where everybody knows everybody. The food is really good. It’s always on time. Very seldom do they ever make a mistake. Very friendly and cordial and very very busy all the time. Which is a good sign because there’s a lot of people who are obviously happy to shop there
… more
Jessica Wenban
Love, love, love dustins! The food is amazing, staff is always super friendly, and the prices are so fair.
… more
Richie Ludolph
It’s two star solely because I haven’t tried the food. I just moved to brockport and found Dustin’s looking for a more local pizza place. Upon ordering for delivery the employee seemed very short and annoyed I was ordering. But that’s fine everyone has a bad day sometimes. After finishing my order he asked where it was going and I said my address in brockport. The employee quickly said we don’t deliver to brockport and hung up on me. Had he stayed on the line I would’ve switched to pick up but I guess there wasn’t time for that or the option. Very disappointed as I’ve seen good reviews for this place and it was recommended but one bad employee can really turn you off a place. I may try Dustin’s another time but as far as first impressions it was a poor one.
… more
Rob&Krys’s Entertainment
Been coming here for over 10 years. My visit last week, they screwed up my order $70!!. Came today to see if they’d do anything for the screw up…..nothing!!! Poor customer support! May never come back.
… more
Kathleen Crandon
Always yummy! I usually order delivery, the food is hot and delivered timely.
… more
Heather The Traveling Mom
Tried Dustin’s for the first time. I got pink sauce which was really good. A combination of white and red sauce. It was a thick crust. Nice and soft and cooked all the way through. Lots of toppings which is great. Tasted real good. It was nice to finally have real pizza unlike what my son and husband like to eat. Took normal amount of time. They offered limited amount of seating meeting social distancing rules but I took my meal to the falls across the street to eat. Will be back when in town.
… more
Joshua Curtiss
Clearly those soggy skin flaps are far from X crispy as on paper… its like rubber. What a joke, hopefully everyone can see this
… more
chrissybell100
We had a slice of fresh cheese and pepperoni pizza and a meatball sub…delicious!!!!
… more
James Dunn
Haven’t had a bad meal yet !! Best pizza joint in orleans county!!
… more
Shannon Lonnen
Friendly staff. My friend and I love coming here to eat amazing pizza and having some laughs.
… more
… View more