Intimate, relaxed source for Mexican & Latin American cuisine, plus margaritas, beer & tequila. Based on 488 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
275 NY-25A # 1, Miller Place, NY 11764
Phone: (631) 928-3864
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jill Davenport
Absolutely love Don’s. I’ve been going to the Miller Place location over the last 15 years. I have an appreciation for small family run businesses that give their everything to make it work. These guys you can tell put their all into it. Not only is the food on point, the restaurant is clean, the staff is respectful do a great job. The owner often will throw in a complimentary shot/drink or appetizer. Leaving there, you feel happy, full and appreciated. Highly recommend.
… more
Pat Koehnlein
We love Don Quijote Restaurant! The food, service and atmosphere are exemplary. The decor is warm, cheery and very welcoming. The wait staff is courteous, efficient and accommodating.
… more
Michelle Mieszala
Very festive place! The food is always great! So are the cocktails! Our waiter was awesome! A person from our table went outside for a minute when we were ordering drinks and our waiter ran out to see if he wanted another drink! That is great service!!!
… more
Johanna Z
I adore everything about this location Food and staff are amazing. Super cozy.
… more
Connie Henriquez Kimmel
SOOOO DELISH!!! Went out to lunch with my mom and sister!! We LOVE this place for Mexican! We go to all of them even the one in Patchogue depending where we are! We started with chips AND margaritas OF COURSE , my mom and Nat had the seafood soup and I got the garlic soup that I LOVEEE!! Then we all had the Shrimp Chipotle as our main meal with a side of sour cream!! We get this dish all the time as we love it! We do request it comes on a platter as you see in the pic! Otherwise I believe it normally comes in a skillet! So depends on what you prefer! They used to only make the platter style so we love the lettuce and tomatoes and always request the old way! Then we had ANOTHER round of margaritas and topped it off with flan! Everything was EXCELLENT ~ and we were all super stuffed for lunch! ~ def recommend!!! (Oh~ and my mom doesn’t drink alcohol , so she orders some mango smoothie she loves!)
… more
Gregory Barbera
Always good food. It is hard to have any conversation with your guests because the live music is too loud.
… more
Lisa Lichelle Hill
⚡Lisa – I Love this place. Excellent cozy, beautiful, romantic dining area. Nice bar area. Outstanding outside dining areas! Their staff is friendly, efficient, fast, & always on point!!! Their customers love them. Don Quixote’s in Miller Place, NY. Awesome
… more
RC RC
My little sister birthday: Definitely a bad experience, first of all our server got a bad attitude when we asked for an extra chair to our 7 tab mind you the restaurant was half way empty. She kept coming to our table asking us if we were ready to order but we only had three minutes that we just sat down with TWO MENUS! Only!!!. We’ve had been to this place several times and we never got this type of treatment, it was really uncomfortable in every avenue. My mother tried ordering something for her and I ended up explaining the m nu while the server is looking at us stank. In general it was a really uncomfortable experience and definitely not worth the money. 30$ for a plate of food but the rice, meat & shrimp chewy as hell!. Come on! I don’t know what was really going through their mind. At the end we asked for the check tip was included which it’s fine, however they decided to do 20%!! Without letting us know, 18% it’s the legal tip percentage for a table of 8! Server did not deserve 20% whatsoever however, we saw it and we let it ride because we understand how it is to work at a restaurant. Moving forward definitely not coming back to this restaurant; you won’t get nowhere if you don’t know how to treat your customers but thanks for the ugly experience anyways.
… more
Mike Borrayo
The drinks were ok, the food was terrible the dessert was delicious. I ordered the fajitas Sancho $28 to be exact , the whole meal was covered in some super sweet tomato sauce, all veggies were over cooked but the beans had this overpowering taste of cumin that just killed the whole meal for everyone on our table. The appetizer queso fondue was microwaved cheez whiz and the tab a whopping 175 for 3 people, never again
… more
Christopher Sinclair
Went for restaurant week. Not impressed. Steak was chewy and small portion, dessert was small portion. Wrong beans were given with meal. Chicken was chewy as if frozen. Shrimp were definitely frozen. Can’t recommend. There are many other mexican restaurants that are much better for the money.
… more
… View more