Based on 41 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11295 OH-18, Fostoria, OH 44830
Phone: (419) 701-7028
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Heidi Weiland
I love chicken bacon ranch pizza… ive had a lot of chicken bacon ranch pizzas… and this was the best I’ve had! Ive tried different cheesecakes from different places multiple times and its just not for me… Until I tried Kay’s buckeye cheesecake complete with a homemade buckeye! It was amazing. The staff was very friendly and our food was brought out quickly. We will definitely make the 45 minute trip again and spread the word about daddy and Kay’s pizza and cheesecakes. They currently don’t have a sign up so it can be a little tricky for out-of-towners… it is in the venue 18 red building!
… more
Tom Kish
Great Pizza, friendly owners, delicious cheesecakes! If you go, it’s in the Venue 18 Building, and the entrance is on the east side of the building. They don’t skimp on the toppings, and the pizzas are cooked in stone ovens. If they’re busy, you might have to wait, but it will be worth it!
… more
Laura Weiland
The owners are so kind. They even offered to make our specific cheesecake request, if we notified them that were making the trip back because we live over an hour away.
… more
Christina Grover
Amazing pizza!! This is a gem of a pizza place. We have the bacon chicken ranch, hot chicken pizza, all meat sub, and Buckeye cheesecake. All I heard was sounds of mmmmm coming from all my boys. My husband was very happy with the 6” all meat sub and it was so much food he couldn’t move afterwards. Mind you it was $4.99 and had so much meat on it it was like 2 subway subs without all the bread and all the meat. The buckeye cheesecake was the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. It was phenomenal. We haven’t had this good of take out in a very long time. Don’t let the exterior intimidate you it’s worth the venture in!
… more
Liberty Schultz
This was our first time coming and from the looks of the outside it was terrible and it wasn’t any better on the inside. We went on a Tuesday and I guess it’s always wild on Tuesdays. We didn’t order it until we got there, so we got it for take out, next time we’ll definitely order to just pick it up. The pizza was absolutely delicious, the crust was our favorite part! Then they had peanut butter jelly cheesecake and Twix that we decided to try. And oh my gosh they were so good! We live over an hour from here and will definitely be returning.
… more
John Leibacher
we stopped because of great reviews, it was hard to believe, that the building was an actual restaurant. Its a really run down building, that made us second guess eating there. we did get a piece of cheese cake that was good. hopefully you can improve the atmosphere eventually to match the good cheese cake.
… more
Rt 4 Auto
The cheesecake….OMG….the cheesecake! Visited here about a week ago, the pizza has at the perfect thin crust but not too thin! Toppings were fresh and abundant. But the cheesecake! I had the last Buckeye! I can’t wait to try the strawberry crunch, an Oreo one and nutter butter! Definitely worth the drive!
… more
Sarah Cooper
Ordered two pizzas tonight and both were spot on as far as flavor, size, and overall quality of ingredients. Will absolutely be ordering from Daddy and Kay’s again!
… more
Mike Raines
This place is in store for Big things! My wife’s exact words were the Pb&J cheesecake was AMAZING, almost Euphoric lol. It was just that good. Friendly staff and great prices. Definitely a must. Keto people, no worries they have toppings bowls at a good price as well!
… more
Lynn V.
We ordered a bacon chicken ranch pizza, a meatball sub and the raspberry hazelnut cheesecake. A+!! everything tasted amazing and we will definitely be returning.
… more
… View more