Long-running pizzeria chain turning out a menu of standards, including strombolis & calzones. Based on 159 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
11184 Hebron Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008
Phone: (740) 928-2300
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Taizic Sherogan (Taizic)
This one in Buckeye Lake has become our absolute go to pizza place. They have been so extremely kind and helpful to us. They’ve given us a wrong order only once, and actually went back to the store, made another and delivered the right order. They’re just so wonderful there. I haven’t met a staff member I don’t like! They make it so much easier for us when we have both been working and just can’t get groceries, since we’re far out from many towns. Not to mention their pizzas and salads are always fresh and top tier!
… more
Stephanie Jordan
Quick and tasty on a busy Mopar night! Friendly on the phone ordering and at pickup. We could have chosen the chain down the street, but we prefer to support local and they did not disappoint!
… more
Jennifer Graham
My order was incorrect, I wanted Chef salad, minus black olives, add cucumber. Green olives are missing, and I had black olives. 🙁
… more
Michael Crouse
Manager called me names and a drunk, I do not drink and was very rude then threatened me if I ever call back he would charge my card for my canceled order all over blue chesse for my wing order . So if you want pizza or wings I’d suggest not going to buckeye lake crenos pizza cottage and michals are better and more respectfull without child managers
… more
Chris Kirkpatrick
I’ve been coming to the Buckeye Lake and Cedar St ( Newark ) locations for over 4yrs and have not once had a negative experience. Always friendly, on time and the food is always great!
… more
Jon Burwell
Creno’s is consistent. If you have had their pizza and like it, it will be great no matter where you go. I went to this location to pick up pizza for coworkers. It was fun to share a hometown favorite and I was glad it didn’t disappoint.
… more
Kevin Busick
The calzone was pretty good, it comes sliced with a big side of marinara. Price and wait was reasonable too.
… more
Trisha Rodgers
Love the buckeye lake crenos the food is always correct service is outstanding and delivery times are great. Not a single bad thing to say.
… more
Leslie Willis
Promptly done , had it at the counter with a smile on their faces. They made using the coupon I had received via text msg so easy to use. Highly recommend crenos in buckeye lake !
… more
Kelly Seberig
I was going to complain that my bread was not toasted to my liking but Then I took a bite! Oh my goodness, happiness in my mouth!!
… more
… View more